The Right Arm

Table of Contents

• Introduction
• Rules In Understanding Health Reform
• Principles of Health Reform: 1 - 6
• Principles of Health Reform: 7 - 9
• Principles of Health Reform: 10 - 12
• Results of Fanaticism
• Temperance and the Sunday Movement
• What shall we do to weed out these Fanaticism in our Midst?
• Conclusion
• Key Biblical Themes

Introduction

God has given His people precious light concerning the care of the body, the government of appetite, temperance, cleanliness, exercise, rest, and the proper use of those things which He has provided for the preservation of health. This instruction is not given merely for the purpose of extending physical life. The health of the body has a direct relationship to the condition of the mind, and the condition of the mind affects our ability to understand, receive, and obey spiritual truth.

The subject, therefore, deserves careful and prayerful study.

Yet health reform must always be kept in its proper place. It is neither the foundation of salvation nor a substitute for the gospel. Christ is the center. The gospel is the body of the message. Health reform is an important supporting work--the right arm of the body--but the arm must never be mistaken for the body itself.

“The Body--the Arm--the Head. The medical missionary work has never been presented to me in any other way than as bearing the same relation to the work as a whole as the arm does to the body. The gospel ministry is an organization for the proclamation of the truth and the carrying forward of the work for sick and well. This is the body, the medical missionary work is the arm, and Christ is the head over all. Thus the matter has been presented to me.” - Medical Ministry, p 237-238

This distinction is essential because Satan seeks to destroy God's work in two opposite ways. If he cannot persuade people to disregard the light God has given, he may tempt them to carry a legitimate principle beyond its proper boundaries and turn it into an extreme. Thus, both indifference and fanaticism become dangers.

The purpose of this study is therefore not merely to list dietary practices. It is to examine the biblical principles underlying health reform, to understand their proper relationship to the gospel, and to identify the dangers that arise when God's principles are either neglected or carried beyond what Scripture and the Spirit of Prophecy support.

Why are God’s people destroyed?

The prophet Hosea gives a solemn reason:

“My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge: because thou hast rejected knowledge, I will also reject thee, that thou shalt be no priest to me: seeing thou hast forgotten the law of thy God, I will also forget thy children.” Hosea 4:6

Knowledge in itself is not enough. Knowledge must be received, understood, and obeyed. God does not give light merely to increase our intellectual understanding. He gives light so that it may transform our lives. This principle applies to health reform. There is a danger in rejecting God's instruction because it is inconvenient. But there is another danger equally serious: taking one area of truth and making it the measure of everything else. Therefore, our study must begin with the Word of God. The Bible must remain the final standard by which every doctrine, practice, theory, and proposed test is examined:

“To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Isaiah 8:20

Health reform must therefore be studied as part of the larger work of sanctification, not as an isolated system of dietary rules.

KNOWLEDGE MUST LEAD TO TEMPERANCE

The apostle Peter gives us a remarkable progression on what we call "Peter's Ladder":

“And beside this, giving all diligence, add to your faith virtue; and to virtue knowledge; And to knowledge temperance; and to temperance patience; and to patience godliness; And to godliness brotherly kindness; and to brotherly kindness charity. For if these things be in you, and abound, they make you that ye shall neither be barren nor unfruitful in the knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ. But he that lacketh these things is blind, and cannot see afar off, and hath forgotten that he was purged from his old sins. “ 1 Peter 1:5-9

Notice the relationship. Faith is followed by virtue. Virtue is followed by knowledge. Knowledge is followed by temperance. Temperance is followed by patience, godliness, brotherly kindness, and charity. Thus, true health reform cannot be separated from Christian character. Peter does not present temperance as an isolated physical discipline. It belongs within the Christian life. The purpose is not merely to eat correctly, but to bring the entire life under the government of God. Health reform, rightly understood, should therefore help us become more-not less-fruitful in the knowledge of Jesus Christ.

WHY DOES GOD CARE ABOUT OUR PHYSICAL HEALTH?

John expressed the desire that the physical condition of believers would correspond with their spiritual prosperity:

“Beloved, I wish above all things that thou mayest prosper and be in health, even as thy soul prospereth.” 3 John 1:2

The Bible does not separate the physical, mental, and spiritual aspects of human life as though they had no relationship to one another. Paul declares:

“What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own? 20 For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's.” 1 Corinthians 6:19-20

Our bodies belong to God. This does not mean that physical health earns salvation. We are saved by grace through faith in Christ. But because we belong to Christ, we are to honor Him in our bodies as well as in our spirits. Paul summarizes the principle: “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Corinthians 10:31

This is the proper foundation of health reform. Not self-glorification. Not fear. Not legalism. Not superiority over others. But the glory of God.

Why do we eat?

The Bible gives a simple and practical principle:
“Blessed art thou, O land, when thy king is the son of nobles, and thy princes eat in due season, for strength, and not for drunkenness!” Ecclesiastes 10:17

Food was not given merely for the gratification of appetite. There is a difference between eating for strength and living to satisfy appetite. The fall of man itself involved appetite. Eve saw that the forbidden fruit was “good for food,” and she took it despite God's command. Genesis 3:6

Thousands of years later, Satan tempted Christ through appetite:
“If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread.” Matthew 4:3

Christ's answer reveals the greater principle:
“Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.” Matthew 4:4

Christ demonstrated that appetite must remain under the government of God's Word. This is one of the fundamental principles of temperance.

TEMPERANCE IS A CHRISTIAN PRINCIPLE

Paul declared:
“And herein do I exercise myself, to have always a conscience void of offence toward God, and toward men.” Acts 24:16

And when speaking before Felix, Paul reasoned about:
“righteousness, temperance, and judgment to come.” Acts 24:25

Temperance therefore belongs to the preaching of the gospel. It is not merely a medical or dietary subject. It is a question of self-government under the authority of God.

Paul illustrates the principle through the athlete:
“And every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things.” 1 Corinthians 9:25

The Christian life requires discipline. But Christian discipline must never become human self-righteousness. Our discipline is a response to God's grace, not a means of purchasing salvation.

Paul continues:
“But I keep under my body, and bring it into subjection: lest that by any means, when I have preached to others, I myself should be a castaway.” 1 Corinthians 9:27

HEALTH REFORM AND THE THIRD ANGEL'S MESSAGE

Health reform has an important place in the closing work of God. But its place must be correctly understood. The health message is not independent of the gospel. It serves the gospel. The principle can be illustrated by the human body. The arm performs an important function, but the arm is not the head. The arm is not the body. And the arm certainly cannot replace the head. Christ must remain the Head.

Paul says:
“And he is the head of the body, the church.” Colossians 1:18

Every true branch of Christian work must therefore remain connected to Christ. Health reform should help prepare people physically, mentally, and spiritually to receive and live the truth. It should open doors for ministry, relieve suffering, teach temperance, and demonstrate the practical love of Christ. But if health reform becomes detached from Christ, its proper purpose has been lost.

HEALTH REFORM MUST NEVER REPLACE THE GOSPEL

There is a danger of becoming so occupied with food, diet, exercise, disease prevention, or physical purity that the central truths of salvation are pushed into the background.

The apostle Paul gives us the proper center:
“For I determined not to know any thing among you, save Jesus Christ, and him crucified.” 1 Corinthians 2:2

This does not mean that Paul rejected practical Christian living. Rather, it means that Christ and His saving work remain the foundation of everything else. A person may have an excellent diet and yet possess a proud heart. He or she may understand nutrition and yet not understand the gospel. He or she may avoid certain foods while harboring bitterness, selfishness, pride, or an unforgiving spirit. Therefore, true reform must reach the character. The purpose of health reform is not simply to produce healthier bodies. It is to place the entire person under the government of God.

THE DANGER OF EXTREMES

The history of God's people demonstrates that error can arise on either side of truth. Some reject reform altogether. Others accept a principle and carry it beyond its proper boundaries. The latter danger is especially serious because it can make people despise genuine truth.

The Testimonies warned:

“We have found in our experience that if Satan cannot keep souls bound in the ice of indifference, he will try to push them into the fire of fanaticism.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 5, p. 644

And then continued by explaining that when the Spirit of God is working, Satan seeks to mingle human traits and human devisings with the work of God, resulting in unwise movements. This principle is extremely important in studying health reform. The existence of fanaticism does not prove that health reform is false. And the existence of genuine health reform does not justify fanaticism. We must distinguish between God's principle and man's extreme application of that principle.

APPETITE AND CHURCH DIFFICULTIES

The Testimonies contains an important warning concerning the relationship between appetite, the mind, and church life. The gratification of appetite and intemperate eating could affect the digestive system, the brain, judgment, and rational thinking, and could consequently become a source of church difficulties.

"The abuses of the stomach by the gratification of appetite are the fruitful source of most church trials. Those who eat and work intemperately and irrationally, talk and act irrationally. An intemperate man cannot be a patient man. It is not necessary to drink alcoholic liquors in order to be intemperate. The sin of intemperate eating, eating too frequently, too much, and of rich, unwholesome food, destroys the healthy action of the digestive organs, affects the brain, and perverts the judgment, preventing rational, calm, healthy thinking and acting. And this is a fruitful source of church trials. Therefore in order for the people of God to be in an acceptable state with Him, where they can glorify Him in their bodies and spirits which are His, they must with interest and zeal deny the gratification of their appetites, and exercise temperance in all things. Then may they comprehend the truth in its beauty and clearness, and carry it out in their lives, and by a judicious, wise, straightforward course give the enemies of our faith no occasion to reproach the cause of truth." - Testimonies for the Church, vol.1, p. 618

This is significant. Health reform is not merely about the physical body. The physical condition can affect the mind. The mind affects judgment. Judgment affects conduct. Conduct affects relationships. And relationships affect the peace and unity of the church. Therefore, health reform has a legitimate spiritual dimension. But we must be careful not to reverse the argument and conclude that every church problem is caused by diet. It's true that intemperance is one of a fruitful source of church trials but not the sole explanation for every conflict. This distinction will become important later when we study fanaticism.

THE BIBLICAL PRINCIPLE OF CHRISTIAN UNITY

Why should we study health reform together as a church? Because God desires His people to be united in truth.

Paul wrote:
“Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you; but that ye be perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.” 1 Corinthians 1:10

But biblical unity does not mean that everyone must have identical personal preferences in every matter. True unity is unity in Christ and in the truth of God's Word. (Read the study on True Unity here) Therefore, health reform must never become a weapon for judging, condemning, or separating from brethren over matters that God has not made tests of fellowship. At the same time, we must not use Christian liberty as an excuse to reject clear biblical principles. The answer is neither indifference nor fanaticism. The answer is Bible-based reform under the government of the Holy Spirit.

“IT IS WRITTEN” MUST BE OUR TEST

Christ met Satan's temptations with the Word of God. Again and again He said: “It is written.” Matthew 4:4, 7, 10

This must also be our method. Every health principle must be examined carefully. Every proposed test must be tested. Every claim about diet must be tested. Every interpretation of Ellen White's statement must be tested. Every teaching that claims to be present truth must be tested. The Bible remains the foundation.

“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” 1 Thessalonians 5:21

We should therefore never make a doctrine, test, or requirement out of something merely because a person has strongly advocated it. God's Word must remain the final authority.

HEALTH REFORM IS PART OF A LARGER REFORMATION

The Bible speaks of a work of restoration:
“And he shall send Jesus Christ, which before was preached unto you: Whom the heaven must receive until the times of restitution of all things, which God hath spoken by the mouth of all his holy prophets since the world began.” Acts 3:20-21

God's final work involves restoration. But restoration is not merely physical. God desires restoration of truth, worship, character, family life, Christian conduct, health, and every other area in which sin has brought disorder. Yet all true reformation must be connected with spiritual revival. The first concern must therefore be the heart. David prayed: “Create in me a clean heart, O God; and renew a right spirit within me.” Psalm 51:10

A changed diet without a changed heart is not the complete work of reformation. A changed lifestyle without surrender to Christ is not the complete work of reformation. A changed outward practice without inward conversion can produce only another form of self-righteousness. True reform begins with Christ.

THE PURPOSE OF THIS STUDY

This study therefore has several purposes.

First, to establish health reform upon the foundation of Scripture.

Second, to examine the principles of health reform in their proper order and relationship.

Third, to understand why health reform has been entrusted to God's people.

Fourth, to understand the relationship between health reform, temperance, medical missionary work, and the gospel.

Fifth, to expose the dangers of fanaticism and extremism without weakening genuine reform.

Sixth, to distinguish God's revealed principles from human theories, personal preferences, and imposed tests.

And finally, to place everything under the headship of Jesus Christ.

The ultimate question is not merely: “What should I eat?” The deeper question is: “Who governs my life?” If Christ governs the life, He will also govern the appetite. If Christ governs the mind, He will also govern our choices. If Christ governs the church, He will teach His people how to reform without fanaticism, how to stand firmly without becoming harsh, and how to present truth without misrepresenting the character of God.

THE RIGHT ARM MUST REMAIN CONNECTED TO THE BODY

The expression “right arm” is important because it establishes both the importance and the limitation of health reform. An arm is useful. An arm is necessary for many functions. An arm can extend the work of the body. But an arm cannot function independently of the body. And the arm cannot replace the head. So it is with health reform. Health reform has an important work to accomplish. Medical missionary work has an important work to accomplish. Temperance has an important work to accomplish. But Christ remains the Head. The gospel remains central. The Word of God remains the foundation. The third angel's message remains the message God has entrusted to His people. Health reform is to support, strengthen, and help advance that work. It must never become detached from it.

THE BALANCE WE MUST MAINTAIN

Throughout this study we must therefore guard against two opposite errors.

ERROR #1: INDIFFERENCE
“I do not need to know anything about health reform.”
This attitude rejects light and disregards the responsibility God has given us.

ERROR #2: FANATICISM
“My particular understanding of health reform is the standard by which everyone else must be judged.”
This attitude goes beyond the Word of God and can turn reform into a source of division.

Between these two extremes is the path of Christian temperance, wisdom, humility, and obedience. We are not called to go into the fire of fanaticism. Neither are we called to remain frozen in the ice of indifference. We are called to walk in the light God has given.

“But the path of the just is as the shining light, that shineth more and more unto the perfect day.” Proverbs 4:18

In summary

The principles of health reform are not an optional subject for those who desire to live according to God's revealed will. Neither are they a substitute for the gospel. They belong in their proper place. Christ is the Head. The gospel is the center. The Bible is the foundation. Health reform is the right arm. Temperance is part of Christian character. Medical missionary work is an avenue through which the love of Christ may reach suffering humanity. And true reformation must always be united with spiritual revival.

As we proceed through this study, we will therefore examine the principles of health reform carefully, not merely asking, “What does Ellen White say?” but first asking: What saith the Lord? Then we will compare the counsel with Scripture, examine the original Ellen White sources, distinguish principle from human application, and seek to understand how health reform fits into the larger work of preparing a people to meet Jesus Christ. The objective is not fanaticism nor indifference. The objective is Bible truth, Christian temperance, genuine reform, and complete surrender to Jesus Christ our Saviour.

Back to top ⇧

I. RULES IN UNDERSTANDING HEALTH REFORM

Health reform is an important branch of God's work for His people. It is connected with the third angel's message, with the preparation of a people for the coming of the Lord, and with the practical ministry of the gospel. Yet because health reform is important, it must be understood correctly. A genuine principle can be distorted by human ideas. A blessing can become a stumbling block when it is separated from the gospel. A legitimate reform can become fanaticism when personal convictions are elevated into divine requirements. We therefore need clear biblical rules for understanding health reform. The following principles will govern this study.

1. HEALTH REFORM IS CONNECTED WITH THE THIRD ANGEL'S MESSAGE, BUT IT MUST NOT TAKE THE PLACE OF THE MESSAGE

Ellen White's earliest testimonies concerning health reform establish both its importance and its proper limitation.

In 1867 she wrote:
“The health reform is closely connected with the work of the third message, yet it is not the message. Our preachers should teach the health reform, yet they should not make this the leading theme in the place of the message.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.1, p. 559.2

This is one of the most important statements for understanding the subject. Health reform is connected with the third angel's message. It is part of the preparatory work associated with that message. It is an important reform. It is to be taught. It is to be practiced. But it is not to replace the message itself. The distinction is essential. The third angel's message is centered upon the everlasting gospel and calls the world to worship the Creator, to reject the worship of the beast and his image, and to keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus Christ.

“Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.” Revelation 14:12

Health reform must therefore serve this larger work. The same principle is expressed here even more clearly:

“The health reform is as closely related to the third angel’s message as the arm to the body; but the arm cannot take the place of the body. The proclamation of the third angel’s message, the commandments of God and the testimony of Jesus, is the burden of our work.” - Letter 57, 1896 (CD 75)

This gives us the correct relationship: Christ is the Head. The gospel is the center. The third angel's message is the great proclamation. Health reform is the right arm supporting that work. An arm is important, but an arm cannot replace the body. Likewise, health reform is important, but it cannot replace the gospel.

2. HEALTH REFORM IS A BRANCH OF THE GREAT WORK THAT PREPARES A PEOPLE FOR THE COMING OF THE LORD

Health reform is not merely a modern health program. It belongs to a larger work of preparation.

Ellen White wrote:
“December 10, 1871, I was again shown that the health reform is one branch of the great work which is to fit a people for the coming of the Lord. It is as closely connected with the third angel’s message as the hand is with the body.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.3, p. 161.1

This is an important distinction. The purpose of health reform is not simply to make us live longer. It is not simply about physical appearance. It is not merely about preventing disease. It is part of the larger work of bringing the whole person under the government of God.

The apostle Paul declares:
“And the very God of peace sanctify you wholly; and I pray God your whole spirit and soul and body be preserved blameless unto the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.” 1 Thessalonians 5:23

The Christian is to be sanctified wholly. Therefore, the physical, mental, moral, and spiritual aspects of life cannot be treated as though they have no relationship to one another.

3. HEALTH REFORM IS CONNECTED WITH PRESENT TRUTH

Health reform must not be separated from the present work of God.

“The work of health reform connected with the present truth for this time, is a power for good. It is the right hand of the gospel, and often opens fields for the entrance of the gospel.” - Manuscript 16, 1901, par. 16 (1SM 112)

This is a particularly important principle. Notice the order: Health reform is connected with present truth. It is a power for good. It is the right hand of the gospel. It can open fields for the entrance of the gospel. Therefore, health reform should not be presented as an isolated movement. Its purpose is evangelistic, restorative and practical. Its purpose is to help people understand the love and wisdom of God and prepare the way for the reception of greater truth. When properly conducted, health work can serve as an “entering wedge,” (3SM 285) making a way for other truths to reach the heart. That means the success of health reform should not be measured merely by how many people change their diet. The greater question is: Did the reform help bring the person closer to Christ and His truth?

4. HEALTH REFORM MUST REMAIN IN HARMONY WITH THE GOSPEL

Because health reform is the right hand of the gospel, it must remain connected to the gospel. Medical missionary work that is separated from the gospel becomes crippled. The principles of health reform are to be firmly linked with the ministry of the Word and that the restoring influence of health reform is to be part of the great effort to proclaim the gospel.

“Health reform is to stand out more prominently in the proclamation of the third angel’s message. The principles of health reform are found in the Word of God. The gospel of health is to be firmly linked with the ministry of the Word. It is the Lord’s design that the restoring influence of health reform shall be a part of the last great effort to proclaim the gospel message.” - Manuscript 172, 1899, par. 25 (CD 75)

This gives us a safeguard. Health reform must never become an independent religion. It must never become a substitute for justification by faith. It must never become a substitute for repentance. It must never become a substitute for the new birth. It must never become a substitute for obedience to God. And it must never become a substitute for the proclamation of the three angels' messages.

The health message should lead people toward the great Physician:
Luke 5:31 “And Jesus answering said unto them, They that be whole need not a physician; but they that are sick.”

Christ must remain the center of every branch of Christian ministry.

5. HEALTH REFORM MUST NOT ECLIPSE THE GREAT MESSAGE

We must therefore guard against allowing a secondary matter to eclipse the central burden of the gospel. We are warned that even legitimate reform could be presented in such a way that it would give an erroneous impression of the work and create prejudice.

“The time has come when health reform will be received in its importance by many in high places and in low places. But we are to allow nothing to eclipse the message we have to bear, the third angel's message, connected with the messages of the first and second angel. We must not allow minor things to bind us in a small circle, where we cannot obtain access to the people at large.” - Letter 39, 1901 (CD 209)

The principle is simple: Never allow a branch to obscure the body. The third angel's message must remain prominent. Health reform should support it. Medical missionary work should support it. Temperance should support it. Education should support it. Literature work should support it. House-to-house labor should support it. Every legitimate branch of Christian work must ultimately serve the larger purpose of proclaiming Christ and His truth.

Paul expressed the proper priority:
1 Corinthians 2:2 “For I determined not to know any thing among you, save Jesus Christ, and him crucified.”

This does not mean Paul ignored practical Christian living. It means that Christ remained the foundation and center of everything he taught. The same principle must govern health reform.

6. HEALTH REFORM SHOULD NOT BE MADE INTO A HUMAN TEST OF FELLOWSHIP

Here we must be especially careful. There is an important difference between saying: “God has given us health principles, therefore we should study and practice them,” and saying: “My personal application of those principles is the standard by which every other Christian must be judged.” The first can be obedience. The second can become fanaticism. We are specifically warned against taking individual statements concerning health reform and turning them into universal tests.

“We wish to present temperance and health reform from a Bible standpoint, and to be very cautious not to go to extremes in abruptly advocating health reform. Let us be careful not to graft into health reform one false shoot according to our own peculiar over-strained ideas and weave into it our own strong traits of character making these as the voice of God and passing judgment on all who do not see as we do. It takes time to educate away from wrong habits.” – Manuscript 5, 1881, par. 7 (3SM 284)
“Questions are coming in from brethren and sisters making inquiries in regard to health reform. Statements are made that some are taking the light in the testimonies upon health reform and making it a test. They select statements made in regard to some articles of diet that are presented as objectionable, statements written in warning and instruction to certain individuals who were entering or had entered on an evil path. They dwell on these things and make them as strong as possible, weaving their own peculiar, objectionable traits of character in with these statements and carry them with great force, thus making them a test and driving them where they do only harm.” – Manuscript 5, 1881, par. 8 (3SM 285)

And we are then warned against adding human ideas to the health message and presenting those ideas as though they were the voice of God.

This is a critical rule for this entire study: WE MUST DISTINGUISH BETWEEN GOD'S PRINCIPLE AND OUR PERSONAL APPLICATION OF THAT PRINCIPLE.

The fact that God has given light does not give us permission to manufacture additional tests. The fact that one statement was given in counsel to an individual does not automatically make every detail of that counsel a universal test for every person in every circumstance. The fact that one food may be harmful does not mean that every person must be judged by exactly the same application. The fact that a reform is important does not mean that every disagreement over its application constitutes apostasy. Therefore, we must study the whole counsel carefully.

7. DO NOT TAKE STATEMENTS OUT OF THEIR CONTEXT

One of the greatest dangers in studying the Spirit of Prophecy is to isolate a sentence from the circumstances in which it was given. Ellen White specifically addressed this problem in connection with health reform. She wrote that some were taking statements concerning particular articles of diet, selecting warnings given to individuals, and making those statements into tests for everyone. She warned that they were: “weaving their own peculiar, objectionable traits of character in with these statements” and making them a test, thereby doing harm.

"Questions are coming in from brethren and sisters making inquiries in regard to health reform. Statements are made that some are taking the light in the testimonies upon health reform and making it a test. They select statements made in regard to some articles of diet that are presented as objectionable—statements written in warning and instruction to certain individuals who were entering or had entered on an evil path. They dwell on these things and make them as strong as possible, weaving their own peculiar, objectionable traits of character in with these statements and carry them with great force, thus making them a test, and driving them where they do only harm." – Manuscript 5, 1881, par. 8 (3SM 285)

This gives us a vital principle of interpretation: Read the whole testimony.

Ask:

• Who was being addressed?
• What was the circumstance?
• What problem was being corrected?
• Was the counsel individual or general?
• Was the statement a principle or a specific application?
• What does the Bible say about the subject?
• What other statements did Ellen White make on the same subject?
• Is the conclusion consistent with the whole body of inspired counsel?

We must never build a doctrine from an isolated sentence.

The apostle Paul gives us the principle: 2 Timothy 2:15 “Rightly dividing the word of truth.”

8. HEALTH REFORM MUST BE PRESENTED FROM A BIBLE STANDPOINT

Health reform is not to be founded upon human philosophy. It is not to be founded upon popular health trends. It is not to be founded upon personal theories. It must be presented from a biblical standpoint.

“We wish to present temperance and health reform from a Bible standpoint.” - Manuscript 5, 1881, par. 7 (3SM 284)

This is exactly the approach we must take. The Bible establishes the foundation. The Spirit of Prophecy gives inspired counsel that illuminates and applies principles. Human science may provide useful information, but it must never become the foundation of Christian doctrine.

Our starting point must therefore be: “It is written.” Matthew 4:4, 7, 10

“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” 1 Thessalonians 5:21

9. DO NOT ABRUPTLY FORCE REFORM UPON PEOPLE

Health reform involves habits. Habits that have existed for years-or even for a lifetime-are not always changed instantly. Therefore, truth must be presented with wisdom.

“It takes time to educate away from wrong habits.” - Manuscript 5, 1881, par. 7 (3SM 284)

This principle should govern our evangelistic work. We must not compromise truth. But neither should we destroy the influence of truth through harshness. The Saviour's method was different. He met people where they were and led them toward something better. When Christ spoke with the Samaritan woman, He did not begin by attacking her. He directed her attention toward the greater gift:

John 4:10 “If thou knewest the gift of God, and who it is that saith to thee, Give me to drink; thou wouldest have asked of him, and he would have given thee living water.”

The lesson is powerful. Lead people to Christ first. As they come to know Christ, they will become willing to follow His Word. Health reform should therefore be presented as a blessing rather than as a weapon.

10. DO NOT USE HARSH OR HASTY MEASURES

The Testimonies gave specific counsel concerning the meat question that illustrates a broader principle of teaching health reform.

“In regard to this matter there should be no rash movements. We should consider the situation of the people, and the power of life-long habits and practices, and should be careful not to urge our ideas upon others, as if this question were a test, and those who eat largely of meat were the greatest of sinners.” - Letter 102, 1896, par. 4 (CD 462.1)
“All should have the light on this question, but let it be carefully presented. Habits that have been thought right for a lifetime are not to be changed by harsh or hasty measures.” - Letter 102, 1896, par. 5 (CD 462.2)

This does not mean that we should hide truth. It does not mean that we should excuse wrong habits. It means that the method of presenting truth matters. The truth is not strengthened by cruelty. The truth is not advanced by humiliation. The truth is not made more powerful by condemning people. We should teach clearly, practice faithfully, and allow the Holy Spirit to convict the conscience.

11. HEALTH REFORM SHOULD BE TAUGHT BY EXAMPLE

A particularly important principle in the same counsel is that health reform must be supported by example.

“While the principles of health reform should be presented, let the teaching be backed by example. Let no meat be found at our restaurants or dining tents, but let its place be supplied with fruits, grains, and vegetables. We must practice what we teach. When sitting at a table where meat is provided, we are not to make a raid upon those who use it, but we should let it alone ourselves, and when asked our reasons for doing this, we should in a kindly manner explain why we do not use it. We must practice what we teach.” - Letter 102, 1896, par. 5

This principle applies far beyond diet. A health reformer who is harsh, impatient, proud, argumentative, and judgmental may cause people to reject the very truth being presented. The reformer must therefore demonstrate the fruits of reform. Temperance should produce self-control. Health reform should produce usefulness. Physical discipline should strengthen service. Proper diet should support mental clarity. Self-denial should produce humility. Reform should produce Christlike character. Otherwise, the outward reform has failed to accomplish its greater purpose.

12. HEALTH REFORM SHOULD NOT CREATE PREJUDICE AGAINST THE GOSPEL

We are warned that health reform, when presented unwisely, could create prejudice and close doors that might otherwise have been open to the truth. When health reform is properly treated, it can become an “entering wedge,” but when it is made the burden of the message, it can create prejudice and leave the impression that God's people are extremists.

“Health reform, wisely treated, will prove an entering wedge where the truth may follow with marked success. But to present health reform unwisely, making that subject the burden of the message, has served to create prejudice with unbelievers and to bar the way to the truth, leaving the impression that we are extremists. Now the Lord would have us wise and understanding as to what is His will. We must not give occasion for us to be regarded extremists. This will place us and the truth God has given us to bear to the people at a great disadvantage. Through weaving in unconsecrated self, that which we are ever to present as a blessing becomes a stumbling block.” - Manuscript 5, 1881, par. 10

This is a solemn warning. We must never present the truth in such a way that people reject Christ because they have encountered our spirit rather than His.

The apostle Peter instructs:
1 Peter 3:15 “But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear.”

Truth must be accompanied by the character of Christ.

13. FANATICISM IS NOT REFORM

True reform and fanaticism must never be confused. Reform means returning to God's principles. Fanaticism means carrying a principle beyond its proper boundaries or adding human ideas and presenting them as divine requirements.

“We have found in our experience that if Satan cannot keep souls bound in the ice of indifference, he will try to push them into the fire of fanaticism.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.5, p. 644.3

Therefore, Satan can attack health reform from either direction. He can persuade people to reject it. Or he can persuade people to become so extreme that they bring reproach upon it. Both accomplish his purpose. The answer is not to abandon health reform. The answer is to return to Bible-based, Christ-centered, balanced reform

14. THERE MUST BE NO “PREMATURE TIME OF TROUBLE”

Another important principle is that we must not create unnecessary restrictions before God requires them. Ellen White repeatedly warned against premature and extreme measures.

"The time will come when we may have to discard some of the articles of diet we now use, such as milk and cream and eggs, but my message is that you must not bring yourself to a time of trouble beforehand, and thus afflict yourself with death. Wait till the Lord prepares the way before you...." - Letter 37, 1901 (CD 358)

The principle is especially important when circumstances differ between countries, cultures, climates, economic situations, and individual physical conditions. God's people should seek to follow the highest principles of healthful living. But we should not manufacture crises that God has not commanded. We should not make every future possibility an immediate test. We should not impose upon others restrictions that God has not made universal. Instead: Study. Understand. Pray. Practice. Teach. Advance according to the light received.

15. HEALTH REFORM IS AN INDIVIDUAL WORK

One of the strongest statements concerning health reform is found in Testimonies for the Church, volume 1:

“It is an individual work; one cannot do it for another.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.1, p. 486.2

Ellen White connects this work with preparation for the loud cry and with the need for God's people to understand their own physical constitution. This means that we cannot live someone else's health reform for them. We can teach. We can encourage. We can provide an example. We can warn. We can pray. But we cannot force another person's conscience.

The principle is consistent with Paul's statement:
Romans 14:12 “So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God.”

Therefore, health reform requires personal conviction and personal responsibility before God.

16. HEALTH REFORM MUST PRODUCE SELF-MASTERY

The ultimate goal is not simply a list of foods we consume or avoid. The greater issue is self-government. The Testimonies connected the health reform with self-mastery and warned about the power of appetite over the intellect and moral faculties.

“Gluttony is the prevailing sin of this age. Lustful appetite makes slaves of men and women, and beclouds their intellects and stupefies their moral sensibilities to such a degree that the sacred, elevated truths of God’s word are not appreciated. The lower propensities have ruled men and women.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.1, p. 486.2

The Bible gives the same principle:
1 Corinthians 9:25 “And every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things.”

Temperance means that appetite does not become our master. Christ is our Master. The body is to serve the mind. The mind is to be surrendered to God. And the whole person is to be governed by the Holy Spirit.

17. HEALTH REFORM MUST LEAD TOWARD CHRISTLIKE CHARACTER

The ultimate evidence of genuine reform is not merely a changed menu. It is a changed life. A person may become extremely strict in diet and still remain selfish. A person may become highly knowledgeable about nutrition and remain impatient. A person may reject certain foods and still indulge pride. A person may be physically disciplined while spiritually undisciplined. Therefore, the health reform must contribute to the greater work of character development.

Paul writes:
1 Corinthians 9:25 “And every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things.”

And temperance is itself a fruit of the Spirit:
Galatians 5:22-23 “But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith, Meekness, temperance: against such there is no law.”

True health reform should therefore make us: more temperate, more patient, more humble, more useful, more clear-minded, more self-controlled, and more Christlike. If a supposed reform produces pride, condemnation, division, and harshness, we must stop and examine whether we have truly understood the spirit of reform.

18. THE GOVERNING PRINCIPLE: “WHAT SAITH THE LORD?”

We therefore establish the following rules for this study:

RULE 1 - The Bible is the foundation of health reform.

RULE 2 - Health reform is connected with the third angel's message but is not to replace the message.

RULE 3 - Health reform is the right arm of the gospel and should remain connected with the body.

RULE 4 - Health reform should help prepare God's people for the coming of the Lord.

RULE 5 - Health reform must be presented in harmony with the gospel.

RULE 6 - Health reform must not be turned into a human test where God has not made it one.

RULE 7 - Individual statements must not be isolated from their context.

RULE 8 - Personal applications must not be elevated into universal commandments without biblical support.

RULE 9 - Reform must be presented with wisdom, patience, meekness, and Christian love.

RULE 10 - We must practice what we teach.

RULE 11 - Fanaticism must be rejected without rejecting genuine reform.

RULE 12 - Christ must remain the Head and the gospel must remain the center.

In summary

The right understanding of health reform can be summarized in one picture:

THE HEAD - CHRIST
Christ is the Head of the body.

THE BODY - THE GOSPEL AND THE CHURCH'S GREAT COMMISSION
The proclamation of the everlasting gospel, including the first, second, and third angels' messages, is the great work entrusted to God's people.

THE RIGHT ARM - HEALTH REFORM
Health reform supports, strengthens, and opens doors for that work.

"The Body--the Arm--the Head. The medical missionary work has never been presented to me in any other way than as bearing the same relation to the work as a whole as the arm does to the body. The gospel ministry is an organization for the proclamation of the truth and the carrying forward of the work for sick and well. This is the body, the medical missionary work is the arm, and Christ is the head over all. Thus the matter has been presented to me." - Medical Ministry, p. 237-238

Therefore, the arm must remain connected to the body. And both must remain under the direction of the Head. When health reform is neglected, the work suffers. When health reform is separated from the gospel, the work is crippled. When health reform replaces the gospel, the order is reversed. When health reform is turned into fanaticism, the blessing becomes a stumbling block. But when health reform is understood from Scripture, practiced with wisdom, presented in the spirit of Christ, and united with the gospel, it becomes what God designed it to be: the right arm of the gospel-serving the body, directed by Christ, and helping prepare a people to stand faithful in the closing work of God.

Back to top ⇧

II. PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH REFORM: 1-6

Health reform is broader than a list of foods that may or may not be eaten. It is a system of principles governing the relationship between the body, the mind, the appetite, and the service of God. The foundation is not merely “What shall I eat?” The deeper question is: “How may I keep my body and mind in the best condition to glorify God and serve Him?”

Paul gives us the governing principle:
1 Corinthians 10:31 “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.”

Health reform therefore begins with temperance, proceeds to proper nourishment, requires the avoidance of harmful substances, includes the proper preparation and combination of food, recognizes the importance of rest, exercise, fresh air, and regularity, and ultimately seeks self-control over appetite and passion. These principles should not be separated from one another.

PRINCIPLE 1 — TEMPERANCE IN ALL THINGS

Temperance Is the Foundation

The first principle of health reform is temperance. Temperance means bringing the appetites, passions, habits, and desires under the control of reason and conscience, in harmony with God's Word.

Paul writes:
1 Corinthians 9:25 “And every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things.”

Temperance is therefore not merely abstinence from intoxicating substances. It includes moderation in eating, drinking, working, sleeping, recreation, and every other legitimate activity. There can be intemperance even in something that is otherwise good. A person can overeat wholesome food. A person can overwork. A person can overeat fruit. A person can become excessive in exercise. A person can become so absorbed in health reform that health reform itself becomes an obsession. Therefore, the principle is not merely: “Avoid bad things.” It is: “Exercise self-control in all things.”

Paul places temperance within the development of Christian character:
2 Peter 1:5-6 “And beside this, giving all diligence, add to your faith virtue; and to virtue knowledge; And to knowledge temperance; and to temperance patience; and to patience godliness.”

Temperance is therefore part of sanctification. It is not merely a physical discipline. It is a spiritual discipline.

Temperance Is Not Legalism

We must distinguish biblical temperance from legalism. Legalism attempts to gain righteousness through human performance. Christian temperance is the response of a person who has surrendered to Christ.

Paul says:
1 Corinthians 6:20 “For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's.”

We do not practice temperance in order to earn God's love. We practice temperance because we already belong to Him. The body belongs to God. The mind belongs to God. The appetite belongs under God's government. The entire life is to be placed upon the altar.

Romans 12:1 “I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, that ye present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable unto God, which is your reasonable service.”

PRINCIPLE 2 — PROPER, NATURAL, WHOLESOME FOOD

Food Was Given for Nourishment, Not Merely Pleasure

God gave food to humanity for nourishment. At creation, God said:
Genesis 1:29 “Behold, I have given you every herb bearing seed... and every tree, in the which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat.”

The original diet was therefore centered upon the wholesome provisions God had made. After the entrance of sin, the human diet became more complicated. Yet the fundamental principle remains: Food should sustain life and strength rather than become the master of appetite.

Ecclesiastes gives the principle:
Ecclesiastes 10:17 “Blessed art thou, O land, when thy king is the son of nobles, and thy princes eat in due season, for strength, and not for drunkenness!”

We eat for strength, not merely for pleasure.

Taste Must Not Become Our Master

We are warned against allowing taste and pleasure to govern the life.

“Taste and pleasure, instead of the glory of God, and a desire to advance in the divine life, and to perfect holiness in the fear of God, have ruled.” - Christian Temperance, p. 26

Then it described the danger of allowing appetite to govern instead of principle. This is the real issue. The question is not whether food tastes good. The question is: Does appetite control me, or does principle control me? There is nothing sinful about enjoying wholesome food. God has provided food that is both nourishing and enjoyable. The problem arises when pleasure becomes the governing principle.

Proper Food Should Be Wholesome and Nourishing

Health reform does not mean starvation. It does not mean eating tasteless food. It does not mean deliberately depriving the body of necessary nourishment. We are warned that extreme and impoverished diets could actually damage health and weaken usefulness. True reform must provide adequate nourishment.

“Because it is wrong to eat merely to gratify a perverted taste, it does not follow that we should be indifferent in regard to our food. It is a matter of the highest importance. No one should adopt an impoverished diet. Many are debilitated from disease, and need nourishing, well-cooked food. Health reformers, above all others, should be careful to avoid extremes. The body must have sufficient nourishment. The God who gives his beloved sleep has furnished them also suitable food to sustain the physical system in a healthy condition.” - Christian Temperance and Bible Hygience, p. 49.3

Therefore: Simple does not mean inadequate. Plain does not mean tasteless. Healthful does not mean impoverished. Temperance does not mean starvation. The body must receive what it needs.

The Meat Question

The subject of flesh foods belongs under this broader principle. The Bible permitted the use of certain animal foods after the Flood and distinguished between clean and unclean animals. Therefore, we must not teach that the Bible itself establishes universal vegetarianism as a condition of salvation. At the same time, Ellen White gave increasingly strong counsel concerning the dangers of flesh foods, particularly as disease in animals increased.

“When will they learn that it is dangerous to use flesh meat? I am instructed to say that if ever meat eating were safe, it is not safe now.” - Manuscript 133, 1902 (CD 384)

This counsel should be presented seriously. But it must also be presented accurately. The same body of counsel warns against making flesh food a test of fellowship. The issue therefore belongs within health reform, but it must not be turned into a man-made standard of salvation or church fellowship. The larger principle is: Choose food according to God's principles rather than according to appetite, habit, or mere pleasure.

PRINCIPLE 3 — AVOIDANCE OF HARMFUL AND INTOXICATING SUBSTANCES

The third principle is the rejection of substances that impair the body, cloud the mind, or weaken self-control. The Bible repeatedly condemns intoxication.

Proverbs 20:1 “Wine is a mocker, strong drink is raging: and whosoever is deceived thereby is not wise.”

Ephesians 5:18 “Be not drunk with wine, wherein is excess; but be filled with the Spirit.”

The contrast is striking. The intoxicating substance controls the person. The Holy Spirit controls the Christian. God desires a clear mind.

Peter writes:
1 Peter 1:13 “Wherefore gird up the loins of your mind, be sober, and hope to the end for the grace that is to be brought unto you at the revelation of Jesus Christ.”
1 Peter 5:8 “Be sober, be vigilant.”

Sobriety is therefore essential to spiritual warfare.

The Principle Goes Beyond Alcohol

The biblical principle extends beyond alcoholic beverages. Anything that unnecessarily enslaves appetite or weakens self-government should be examined carefully. The question is: Does this help me maintain a clear mind and a sound body for the service of God?

Paul says:
1 Corinthians 6:12 “All things are lawful unto me, but all things are not expedient: all things are lawful for me, but I will not be brought under the power of any.” This is a powerful health principle. The Christian must not become enslaved by appetite.

PRINCIPLE 4 — PROPER COMBINATION, PREPARATION, AND MODERATION OF FOOD

Health reform does not end with deciding what we eat. We must also consider how much, how it is prepared, and how different foods are combined. That knowledge concerning proper food combinations is valuable and should be regarded as wisdom from God. We are advised against excessive variety at one meal and emphasized simplicity and thoughtful preparation.

“Knowledge in regard to proper food combinations is of great worth, and is to be received as wisdom from God.” - Letter 213, 1902 (CD 109.4)

“Do not have too great a variety at a meal; three or four dishes are a plenty. At the next meal you can have a change. The cook should tax her inventive powers to vary the dishes she prepares for the table, and the stomach should not be compelled to take the same kinds of food meal after meal.” - RH July 29, 1884

“There should not be many kinds at any one meal, but all meals should not be composed of the same kinds of food without variation. Food should be prepared with simplicity, yet with a nicety which will invite the appetite.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.2, 63

This is practical wisdom. The stomach should not continually be overloaded with complicated mix Testimonies for the Church, vol.1tures. The body needs nourishment, but it also needs moderation.

Solomon wrote:
Proverbs 23:2 “Put a knife to thy throat, if thou be a man given to appetite.”
Proverbs 23:6 “Eat thou not the bread of him that hath an evil eye, neither desire thou his dainty meats.”

The Bible recognizes that appetite can become excessive.

Food Should Be Prepared Properly

Good health reform requires knowledge and skill. We are warned that merely eliminating certain foods does not make someone a genuine health reformer.

“Not all who profess to believe in dietetic reform are really reformers. With many persons the reform consists merely in discarding certain unwholesome foods. They do not understand clearly the principles of health, and their tables, still loaded with harmful dainties, are far from being an example of Christian temperance and moderation.” - Ministry of Healing, p. 318.1

A person may remove one unhealthy article while continuing to prepare an unbalanced, poorly nourished, or monotonous diet. True reform requires understanding. This is why cooking education has an important place in health reform. The preparation of wholesome food should become a practical skill.

Health reform should demonstrate that healthy food can be:

• nourishing,
• simple,
• attractive,
• appetizing,
• properly prepared,
• and sufficient for the needs of the body.

The Testimonies emphasized that food reform should not be made so unattractive that people reject the reform itself. It repeatedly instructed those working with others to provide wholesome, nourishing, palatable food.

“Some of these persons call themselves health reformers, but they are not. They do not know how to cook. They prepare cakes, potatoes, and graham bread, but there is the same round, with scarcely a variation, and the system is not strengthened. They seem to think the time wasted which is devoted to obtaining a thorough experience in the preparation of healthful, palatable food.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.1, p. 681.3

Therefore: Health reform is not merely subtraction. It is also education and replacement. If an unhealthy habit is removed, something better should take its place.

Moderation in Quantity

Even wholesome food can become harmful when eaten excessively. Overeating places an unnecessary burden upon the digestive system.

The principle is simple:
1 Corinthians 10:31 “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.”

We should eat enough to sustain the body, but not so much that appetite becomes the master.

PRINCIPLE 5 — REGULARITY, REST, EXERCISE, AND FRESH AIR

Health reform is not limited to diet. God's plan for health includes the entire way of life. The body requires: proper nourishment, fresh air, sunlight, exercise, rest, sleep, cleanliness, and regular habits. These are not separate from health reform. They are part of it.

EXERCISE

Physical activity is necessary for maintaining strength and usefulness. A sedentary life weakens the body.

The principle can be illustrated from Scripture:
Ecclesiastes 5:12 “The sleep of a labouring man is sweet.”

God designed humanity to work.

Before sin entered, Adam was placed in Eden:
Genesis 2:15 “to dress it and to keep it.”

Work and physical activity therefore preceded the fall. Proper labor is a blessing.

REST

Yet work must be balanced by rest. God Himself established the Sabbath:

Exodus 20:9-10 “Six days shalt thou labour, and do all thy work: But the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God.”

Rest is not laziness. Rest is part of God's design.

The Saviour Himself told His disciples:
Mark 6:31 “Come ye yourselves apart into a desert place, and rest a while.”

A person who destroys his health through constant labor is not necessarily demonstrating greater faithfulness. We must learn to recognize the limits of the human organism.

FRESH AIR AND THE ENVIRONMENT

The body also requires clean air. God created humanity in an environment of open air, sunlight, vegetation, and natural surroundings. The Bible repeatedly presents the value of God's creation.

Genesis 1:31 “And God saw every thing that he had made, and, behold, it was very good.”

The health reform principles therefore encourage us to make wise use of God's natural provisions rather than living unnecessarily in conditions that undermine health.

PRINCIPLE 6 — SELF-CONTROL OVER APPETITE AND PASSION

The sixth principle brings the others together. Health reform is ultimately about self-government. The deepest battle is not fought at the dinner table. It is fought in the mind. The question is: Who is in control?

Paul writes:
Galatians 5:16 “This I say then, Walk in the Spirit, and ye shall not fulfil the lust of the flesh.”
Galatians 5:24 “They that are Christ's have crucified the flesh with the affections and lusts.”

The Christian does not allow appetite, passion, or impulse to dictate his course.

Appetite Must Be Under the Government of Reason

Ellen White described taking her stand on health reform from principle rather than taste. She explained that she refused to allow personal appetite to govern her decisions and that she adopted reform because she understood it as a matter of duty.

“I have said that some of you are selfish. You have not understood what I have meant. You have studied what food would taste best. Taste and pleasure, instead of the glory of God, and a desire to advance in the divine life, and to perfect holiness in the fear of God, have ruled. You have consulted your own pleasure, your own appetite; and while you have been doing this, Satan has been gaining a march upon you, and as is generally the case, has frustrated your efforts every time.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.2, p. 360.3

This is the correct foundation. Not: “I do this because everyone else does.” Not: “I do this because my church requires it.” Not: “I do this because I want to appear more righteous.” But: “I understand the principle, I have studied God's Word, I have received the light, and I choose to follow it because I love God.”

Ellen White specifically taught the principle:
“When we adopt the health reform, we should adopt it from a sense of duty, not because somebody else has adopted it.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.2, p. 371.2

DANIEL: A BIBLICAL EXAMPLE OF PRINCIPLED TEMPERANCE

Daniel provides one of the clearest biblical examples of this principle. When Babylon attempted to change his diet and lifestyle, Daniel did not compromise his convictions.

Daniel 1:8 “But Daniel purposed in his heart that he would not defile himself with the portion of the king's meat, nor with the wine which he drank.”

Notice the wording: “Daniel purposed in his heart.” The reform began with a decision of the mind. It was not merely a dietary preference. It was a matter of loyalty to God. Daniel did not allow Babylon to dictate his principles. Yet Daniel also did not behave arrogantly.

He requested:
Daniel 1:12 “Prove thy servants, I beseech thee, ten days.” He allowed the results to demonstrate the wisdom of the course he had chosen.

At the end of the test:
Daniel 1:15 “And at the end of ten days their countenances appeared fairer and fatter in flesh than all the children which did eat the portion of the king's meat.”

God honored Daniel's faithfulness. But the central lesson is not merely vegetarianism. The central lesson is loyalty to God's Word. Daniel had purposed in his heart. Therefore: Health reform must be principle-driven, not appetite-driven.

THE SIX PRINCIPLES IN SUMMARY

We can now see the progression clearly.

PRINCIPLE 1 — TEMPERANCE IN ALL THINGS
Bring appetite, habits, and desires under the government of reason, conscience, and God's Word.

PRINCIPLE 2 — PROPER, NATURAL, WHOLESOME FOOD
Choose food for nourishment, strength, and the glory of God—not merely for gratification of appetite.

PRINCIPLE 3 — AVOIDANCE OF HARMFUL AND INTOXICATING SUBSTANCES
Reject substances that damage the body, cloud the mind, or bring the person under their controlling power.

PRINCIPLE 4 — PROPER COMBINATION, PREPARATION, AND MODERATION OF FOOD
Learn how to prepare wholesome food properly, avoid unnecessary complexity, and eat in moderation.

PRINCIPLE 5 — REGULARITY, REST, EXERCISE, AND FRESH AIR
Recognize that health depends upon the whole pattern of life, including labor, exercise, rest, sleep, fresh air, and proper daily habits.

PRINCIPLE 6 — SELF-CONTROL OVER APPETITE AND PASSION
Bring the physical nature under the government of the mind, and the mind under the government of the Holy Spirit.

A NECESSARY BALANCE

These principles must never be separated from the rules established in the preceding section. Health reform must be: Bible-based, Christ-centered, principle-driven, progressive, practical, individual, and free from fanaticism.

Reformers should not become rigid judges of others. The subject should be studied broadly and deeply and that people differ in constitution and circumstances. We are also warns against making isolated ideas into tests and against trying to correct others by attacking their perceived defects.

“Those who have but a partial understanding of the principles of reform are often the most rigid, not only in carrying out their views themselves, but in urging them on their families and their neighbors. The effect of their mistaken reforms, as seen in their own ill-health, and their efforts to force their views upon others, give many a false idea of dietetic reform, and lead them to reject it altogether.” - Ministry of Healing, p. 318.4

“Do not catch hold of isolated ideas and make them a test, criticizing others whose practice may not agree with your opinion; but study the subject broadly and deeply, and seek to bring your own ideas and practices into perfect harmony with the principles of true Christian temperance. There are many who try to correct the lives of others by attacking what they regard as wrong habits. They go to those whom they think in error, and point out their defects, but do not seek to direct the mind to true principles. Such a course often comes far short of securing the desired results. When we make it evident that we are trying to correct others, we too often arouse their combativeness, and do more harm than good. And there is the danger to the reprover also. He who takes it upon himself to correct others, is likely to cultivate a habit of faultfinding, and soon his whole interest will be in picking flaws and finding defects. Do not watch others, to pick at their faults, or expose their errors. Educate them to better habits by the power of your own example.” - Chistian Temperance and Bible Hygience, p. 120.1

Therefore, we should not confuse firmness in principle with harshness toward people. Daniel was firm. Christ was firm. The apostles were firm. But true firmness does not require an un-Christlike spirit.

THE GOAL OF HEALTH REFORM

The ultimate goal is not merely a better diet. It is a better capacity to serve God. Ellen White expressed the relationship between health and Christian service by emphasizing that our physical powers are to be preserved so that we may give God our best service.

Paul states:
“Know ye not that they which run in a race run all, but one receiveth the prize? So run, that ye may obtain.” 1 Corinthians 9:24
“I therefore so run, not as uncertainly; so fight I, not as one that beateth the air.” 1 Corinthians 9:26

The Christian is preparing for a race. Preparing for a battle. Preparing for service. Therefore, we want the clearest mind, the strongest possible body, and the most disciplined character that can be obtained through God's appointed means. But even this is not the final goal. The final goal is Christlikeness.

“But speaking the truth in love, may grow up into him in all things, which is the head, even Christ.” Ephesians 4:15

Health reform should help us grow into Christ. That is its proper place. That is its proper purpose. And that is why it belongs as the right arm of the gospel.

Back to top ⇧

III. PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH REFORM: 7-9

PRINCIPLE 7 — CLEANLINESS AND PROPER CARE OF THE BODY

Health reform is not limited to food. God's plan for the preservation of health includes the proper care of the entire body. This includes cleanliness, pure air, water, exercise, proper rest, wholesome food, and attention to the laws governing physical life.

“Those who treat the sick should move forward in their important work with strong reliance upon God for His blessing to attend the means which He has graciously provided, and to which He has in mercy called our attention as a people, such as pure air, cleanliness, healthful diet, proper periods of labor and repose, and the use of water.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 561

This gives us a broad picture of health reform. It is not merely a question of what enters the body. It is also a question of how the body is cared for.

7.1 - CLEANLINESS IS PART OF HEALTH REFORM

The Bible establishes the principle of cleanliness. When Israel was encamped in the wilderness, God instructed:

“For the LORD thy God walketh in the midst of thy camp, to deliver thee, and to give up thine enemies before thee; therefore shall thy camp be holy: that he see no unclean thing in thee, and turn away from thee.” Deuteronomy 23:14

God required cleanliness among His people.

“The necessity of personal cleanliness was taught in the most impressive manner.” She further describes the strict attention given to cleanliness in the Israelite camp and the requirement that no refuse be allowed to remain within or around their dwellings. - Ministry of Healing, p. 279-280

“Perfect cleanliness, plenty of sunlight, careful attention to sanitation in every detail of the home life, are essential to freedom from disease and to the cheerfulness and vigor of the inmates of the home.” - Ministry of Healing, p. 276

Therefore, cleanliness is not merely a matter of appearance. It is part of responsible stewardship of the body and the home.

7.2 - PROPER CARE OF THE BODY REQUIRES KNOWLEDGE

God expects us to learn how the body works.

“Our ministers should become intelligent on health reform. They need to become acquainted with physiology and hygiene; they should understand the laws that govern physical life, and their bearing upon the health of mind and soul.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 6, p. 376

This principle applies not only to ministers. Every Christian should seek sufficient understanding to care responsibly for the body God has entrusted to him. We should not deliberately remain ignorant of the laws of health. The body is God's workmanship.

Paul declares:
“Know ye not that ye are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?” 1 Corinthians 3:16
“What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you?” 1 Corinthians 6:19

Therefore, ignorance should not be our excuse when knowledge is available.

7.3 - THERE CANNOT BE ONE PRECISE DIETARY RULE FOR EVERY PERSON

Here we come to an important balance. Health principles are universal. But individual applications can differ.

“There is a wide difference in constitutions and temperaments, and the demands of the system differ greatly in different persons. What would be food for one, might be poison for another; so precise rules cannot be laid down to fit every case.” - Letter 19a, 1891, par. 8 (CD 494)

This principle is extremely important. It does not mean that there are no principles. It means that we must distinguish between: God's principles and our individual application of those principles. For example, the principle of temperance is universal. But the precise quantity or combination of food that works best for every individual may differ. The principle of eating wholesome food is universal. But individual constitutions may respond differently to particular foods. The principle of caring for the body is universal. But individual circumstances may require different applications. Therefore, health reform requires wisdom rather than rigidity.

7.4 - DO NOT MAKE YOURSELF THE STANDARD FOR EVERYONE ELSE

Ellen White's own experience is especially instructive. She wrote:

She explained that there were foods she personally could not eat without suffering, but she did not use her own experience as a universal rule for others.

This principle is crucial. We may say: “This is what I have found beneficial for me.” But we should be cautious about saying: “Because this works for me, everyone must do exactly the same.” Ellen White's household itself provides an example.

"But the other members of my family do not eat the same things that I do. I do not hold myself up as a criterion for them. I leave each one to follow his own ideas as to what is best for him. I bind no one else’s conscience by my own. One person cannot be a criterion for another in the matter of eating. It is impossible to make one rule for all to follow. There are those in family who are very fond of beans, while to me beans are poison. Butter is never placed on my table, but if the members of my family choose to use a little butter away from the table, they are at liberty to do so. Our table is set twice a day, but if there are those who desire something to eat in the evening, there is no rule that forbids them from getting it. No one complains or goes from our table dissatisfied. A variety of food that is simple, wholesome, and palatable is always provided." - Letter 127, 1904, par. 11 (CD 491)

She explained that different members of her family did not eat exactly the same things, and she did not bind their consciences by her own. She wrote that “one person cannot be a criterion for another in the matter of eating” and that it was impossible to make one rule for all. This is not permission for careless eating. It is a warning against making personal experience into divine law.

7.5 - DO NOT BIND ANOTHER PERSON'S CONSCIENCE BY YOUR OWN

This principle reaches beyond diet. A Christian must learn to distinguish between: what God has commanded, what inspired counsel has clearly established, and what is a personal conviction or application.

Paul wrote:
“Who art thou that judgest another man's servant? to his own master he standeth or falleth.” Romans 14:4
“So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God.” Romans 14:12

This does not eliminate Christian responsibility. It eliminates human lordship over the conscience. We teach truth. We give counsel. We demonstrate by example. But God alone is Lord of the conscience.

7.6 - THE DANGER OF SELECTING ONLY THE STRONGEST STATEMENTS

This is particularly important when studying the Testimonies. A person can take a genuine statement and misuse it by removing it from its setting. Ellen White warned about those who: “select from the testimonies the strongest expressions and, without bringing in or making any account of the circumstances under which the cautions and warnings are given, make them of force in every case.” She explained that such a method can produce an unhealthy impression, create unnecessary combativeness, and actually cause people to reject the reform that should have helped them. (Read 3SM 285-286 on Rule #7)

The rule is: Never use an isolated statement to destroy the balance of the entire body of counsel. This is particularly important with health reform because individual statements were sometimes given in response to individual circumstances.

7.7 - DIET SHOULD BE ADAPTED TO CIRCUMSTANCES

Health reform must also recognize differences in: climate, season, occupation, physical constitution, available foods, economic circumstances, age, and individual needs.

“Not all foods wholesome in themselves are equally suited to our needs under all circumstances. Care should be taken in the selection of food. Our diet should be suited to the season, to the climate in which we live, and to the occupation we follow. Some foods that are adapted for use at one season or in one climate are not suited to another. So there are different foods best suited for persons in different occupations.” Ministry of Healing, p. 296

7.8 - THE MEAT QUESTION MUST BE HANDLED WITH WISDOM

The subject of flesh food deserves serious attention, but it must be kept in its proper place. Ellen White's counsel against flesh food became increasingly strong, especially as she recognized the dangers associated with diseased animals and the effects of flesh consumption. Yet she also repeatedly warned against rash movements.

In the Australian context she wrote:
“In regard to this matter there should be no rash movements. We should consider the situation of the people, and the power of lifelong habits and practices, and should be careful not to urge our ideas upon others, as if this question were a test, and those who eat largely of meat were the greatest sinners. All should have the light on this question, but let it be carefully presented. Habits that have been thought right for a lifetime are not to be changed by harsh or hasty measures." - Letter 102, 1896 (CD 462)

This counsel must be understood carefully. It does not mean that health reform should be ignored. It means that reform must be taught wisely.

7.9 - MEAT EATING SHOULD NOT BECOME THE CENTER OF HEALTH REFORM

The danger in an unbalanced study is to make health reform synonymous with the meat question. That would be a mistake. Health reform includes: temperance, wholesome food, cleanliness, exercise, fresh air, rest, proper care of the body, self-control, mental health, spiritual preparation, and many other principles. Flesh food is one important aspect of dietary reform, but it is not the entire health message. The larger principle is: “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Corinthians 10:31

PRINCIPLE 8 — THE CONNECTION BETWEEN PHYSICAL HABITS AND THE MIND

The second major principle in this section is the relationship between the body and the mind. This connection is extremely important because health reform is not merely about physical comfort. It affects the mind. And the mind is the battlefield in which character is developed.

8.1 - THE BODY AFFECTS THE MIND

“Our ministers should become intelligent on health reform. They need to become acquainted with physiology and hygiene; they should understand the laws that govern physical life, and their bearing upon the health of mind and soul.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 6, p. 376

This is an important principle. Our physical condition can affect: mental clarity, judgment, self-control, emotional stability, ability to work, ability to study, and capacity to serve. This is one reason health reform is connected with spiritual preparation.

8.2 - APPETITE CAN AFFECT SPIRITUAL DISCERNMENT

The first temptation involved appetite.
“And when the woman saw that the tree was good for food... she took of the fruit thereof, and did eat.” Genesis 3:6

The first temptation of Christ also involved appetite:
“If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread.” Matthew 4:3

But Christ answered:
“Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.” Matthew 4:4

Christ demonstrated that appetite must remain subordinate to God's Word. The Christian therefore cannot allow physical desire to dictate spiritual decisions.

8.3 - SELF-CONTROL PROTECTS THE MIND

Paul declares:
“But I keep under my body, and bring it into subjection.” 1 Corinthians 9:27

This is not hatred of the body. It is government of the body. The body is not to rule the mind. The mind is not to be ruled by appetite. And the mind must itself be surrendered to God.

Paul therefore says:
“Let this mind be in you, which was also in Christ Jesus.” Philippians 2:5

This is the ultimate objective. Health reform should contribute to the development of a Christlike mind.

8.4 - DANIEL'S EXPERIENCE ILLUSTRATES THE PRINCIPLE

Daniel gives us a biblical example.
“But Daniel purposed in his heart that he would not defile himself with the portion of the king's meat, nor with the wine which he drank.” Daniel 1:8

Notice where the decision began: “Daniel purposed in his heart.” It began with the mind. Daniel understood that participation in the king's provision involved more than appetite. He therefore chose to remain faithful to God. The important lesson is not merely that Daniel rejected certain food. The deeper lesson is that he refused to surrender principle because of appetite or social pressure. His physical decision was an expression of spiritual loyalty.

8.5 - THE BODY AND THE MIND SHOULD WORK TOGETHER IN GOD'S SERVICE

God wants the entire person to be useful. Paul writes:
“Know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God?” 1 Corinthians 6:19

Therefore, our health choices should increase our ability to: think clearly, pray effectively, study God's Word, labor for souls, resist temptation, control appetite, and serve others. Health reform is therefore not ultimately about living for ourselves. It is about being better prepared to serve God and humanity.

PRINCIPLE 9 — HEALTH REFORM AS PREPARATION FOR GREATER SPIRITUAL SERVICE

This is where the entire section reaches its highest purpose. Why did God give health reform? Not merely so that His people could live longer. Not merely so that they could avoid disease. Not merely so that they could discuss food. God desires a people who are physically, mentally, and spiritually prepared for His service.

9.1 - THE BODY IS TO BE PREPARED FOR SERVICE

“Faith and good works should go hand in hand in relieving the afflicted among us, and in fitting them to glorify God here and to be saved at the coming of Christ.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 560

Notice the purpose: “fitting them to glorify God.” This is the goal. Health reform is therefore connected with usefulness. A stronger body should mean greater capacity for service. A clearer mind should mean greater capacity for study. Better self-control should mean greater victory over temptation. Better health should mean greater ability to labor for souls.

9.2 - HEALTH REFORM PREPARES US FOR SPIRITUAL WORK

The health reform was designed to prepare the way for the prayer of faith and to help people glorify God. The connection is therefore both physical and spiritual. God wants His people to understand that: physical preparation supports spiritual service. The Christian who continually destroys his health through known violations of God's principles may unnecessarily weaken his ability to serve.

This is why Paul writes: “And whatsoever ye do, do it heartily, as to the Lord, and not unto men.” Colossians 3:23
Our health belongs to our stewardship.

9.3 - HEALTH REFORM IS PART OF PREPARATION FOR THE FINAL WORK

We must be careful here. Health reform does not prepare us for the final crisis instead of spiritual preparation. It supports it. The greatest preparation is surrender to Christ. The greatest preparation is character transformation. The greatest preparation is receiving the righteousness of Christ. The greatest preparation is obedience to God's Word. But the physical organism is part of the human being through whom God accomplishes His work. Therefore, health reform has a legitimate place in preparation.

9.4 - THE GOSPEL MUST REACH THE WHOLE PERSON

Christ's ministry combined teaching, preaching, and healing. Matthew records:
“And Jesus went about all Galilee, teaching in their synagogues, and preaching the gospel of the kingdom, and healing all manner of sickness and all manner of disease among the people.” Matthew 4:23

The gospel ministry therefore touched the whole person. This is why health reform can become an entering door for evangelism. A person may initially become interested because of health. But the health work should ultimately lead that person to the Great Physician. Christ must remain the destination.

9.5 - MEETING PEOPLE WHERE THEY ARE

One of the most important principles in practical health evangelism is meeting people where they are.

“We must go no faster than we can take those with us whose consciences and intellects are convinced of the truths we advocate. We must meet the people where they are. Some of us have been many years in arriving at our present position in health reform. It is slow work to obtain a reform in diet. We have powerful appetites to meet; for the world is given to gluttony. If we should allow the people as much time as we have required to come up to the present advanced state in reform, we would be very patient with them, and allow them to advance step by step, as we have done, until their feet are firmly established upon the health reform platform. But we should be very cautious not to advance too fast, lest we be obliged to retrace our steps. In reforms, we would better come one step short of the mark than to go one step beyond it. And if there is error at all, let it be on the side next to the people.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 3, p. 20

“There is a wide difference in constitutions and temperaments, and the demands of the system differ greatly in different persons.” - Letter 19am 1891 (CD 494)

“A reform in their habits of eating and drinking is needed. But this reform cannot be made all at once. The change must be made gradually. The health foods set before them must be appetizing. All their lives, perhaps, they have had three meals a day, and have eaten rich food. It is an important matter to reach these people with the truths of health reform. But in order to lead them to adopt a sensible diet, you must set before them an abundant supply of wholesome, appetizing food. Changes must not be made so abruptly that they will be turned from health reform, instead of being led to it. The food served to them must be nicely prepared, and it must be richer than either you or I would eat.” - Letter 331, 1904 (CD 284)

“The change should not be urged to be made abruptly, especially for those who are taxed with continuous labor. Let the conscience be educated, the will energized, and the change can be made much more readily and willingly. The consumptives who are going steadily down to the grave should not make particular changes in this respect, but care should be exercised to obtain the meat of as healthy animals as can be found.” - Letter 54, 1896 (CD 292)

“Among those who are waiting for the coming of the Lord, meat eating will eventually be done away; flesh will cease to form a part of their diet.” - Christian Temperance and Bible Hygience, p. 119

“In some countries, where poverty abounds, flesh is the cheapest food. Under these circumstances, the change will be made with greater difficulty; but it can be effected. We should, however, consider the situation of the people and the power of lifelong habit, and should be careful not to urge even right ideas unduly. None should be urged to make the change abruptly. The place of meat should be supplied with wholesome foods that are inexpensive.” - Ministry of Healing, p. 316

“In regard to this matter there should be no rash movements. We should consider the situation of the people, and the power of lifelong habits and practices, and should be careful not to urge our ideas upon others, as if this question were a test, and those who eat largely of meat were the greatest sinners. All should have the light on this question, but let it be carefully presented. Habits that have been thought right for a lifetime are not to be changed by harsh or hasty measures...” - Letter 102, 1896 (CD 462)

This does not mean compromising truth. It means understanding people's circumstances before attempting to reform them. Consider the Saviour's method. He did not treat every person identically. He met people according to their condition. Likewise, health reform must be presented intelligently. A poor family may not have access to the same foods as a wealthy family. A person in one climate may have different available foods from someone in another. A laborer may have different nutritional needs from a sedentary worker. A sick person may have different immediate needs from a healthy person. A person who has eaten a particular diet for fifty years may require a different educational process from someone who is already accustomed to healthful eating. Therefore: Principles remain firm. Applications may require wisdom.

9.6 - THE PURPOSE IS TO WIN, NOT TO DRIVE AWAY

Health reform should open doors. It should not close them unnecessarily.

Should health reform in its most extreme form be taught to those whose circumstances forbid its adoption, more harm than good would be done." - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 9, p. 163

We are warned against reform being presented so extremely that people would reject the truth because they associated the gospel with harsh and unreasonable restrictions. This is why Christian character is indispensable. We must teach truth with love.

Paul says:
“But speaking the truth in love, may grow up into him in all things, which is the head, even Christ.” Ephesians 4:15

Truth without love becomes harshness. Love without truth becomes compromise. God calls us to truth in love.

9.7 - WHEN HEALTH REFORM BECOMES “HEALTH DEFORM”

There is a legitimate warning here. Health reform can become distorted when people:

• carry a principle beyond what God has revealed,
• create additional tests,
• condemn those who do not follow their personal practice,
• neglect adequate nutrition,
• become obsessed with food,
• damage their health through excessive restriction,
• or make physical reform more important than Christ and the gospel.

"The reforms that are strained to the highest tension might accommodate a certain class, who can obtain all they need to take the place of the things discarded; but this class forms a very small minority of the people, to whom these tests seem unnecessary. There are those who try to abstain from what is declared to be harmful. They fail to supply the system with proper nourishment, and as a consequence become weak and unable to work. Thus health reform is brought into disrepute. The work we have tried to build up solidly is confused with strange things that God has not required. The energies of the church are crippled. But God will interfere to prevent the results of these too-strenuous ideas. The gospel is to harmonize the sinful race. It is to bring the rich and the poor together at the feet of Jesus... But I wish to say that when the time comes that it is no longer safe to use milk, cream, butter, and eggs, God will reveal this. No extremes in health reform are to be advocated. The question of using milk and butter and eggs will work out its own problem. At present we have no burden on this line. Let your moderation be known unto all men." - Letter 37, 1901 (CD 206)

"There are many now under the shadow of death who have prepared to do a work for the Master, but who have not felt that a sacred obligation rested upon them to observe the laws of health. The laws of the physical system are indeed the laws of God, but this fact seems to have been forgotten. Some have limited themselves to a diet that cannot sustain them in health. They have not provided nourishing food to take the place of injurious articles; and they have not considered that tact and ingenuity must be exercised in preparing food in the most healthful manner. The system must be properly nourished in order to perform its work. It is contrary to health reform, after cutting off the great variety of unwholesome dishes, to go to the opposite extreme, reducing the quantity and quality of the food to a low standard. Instead of health reform this is health deform." - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 6, p. 373

The principle is beautifully summarized by Paul:
“Let your moderation be known unto all men. The Lord is at hand.” Philippians 4:5

9.8 - THE GOSPEL MUST ALSO REACH THE POOR

This principle is especially important. Health reform must not become a luxury available only to people with abundant resources. The gospel is for everyone.

Jesus said:
“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he hath anointed me to preach the gospel to the poor.” Luke 4:18

Therefore, health education must take economic realities into account. We should teach people how to use the foods actually available to them. Simple foods can be nutritious. Local foods can be valuable. Affordable foods can often be combined wisely. The objective is not to make people dependent upon expensive specialty foods. The objective is to teach them how to care for the body wisely with the means available to them.

9.9 - HEALTH REFORM MUST BE PROGRESSIVE

Reform often takes time. Ellen White described the health reform as a progressive work and emphasized that light was given increasingly as people were prepared to understand and act upon it.

"The diet reform should be progressive. As disease in animals increases, the use of milk and eggs will become more and more unsafe. An effort should be made to supply their place with other things that are healthful and inexpensive. The people everywhere should be taught how to cook without milk and eggs, so far as possible, and yet have their food wholesome and palatable." - Ministry of Healing, p. 320.2

Therefore, we should not expect everyone to arrive at the same level of understanding overnight. The Christian life itself is progressive. “But the path of the just is as the shining light, that shineth more and more unto the perfect day.” Proverbs 4:18 The principle applies to reform as well. We receive light. We obey the light. God gives greater light. We obey again. The process continues.

9.10 - ELLEN WHITE'S OWN EXPERIENCE ILLUSTRATES PROGRESSIVE REFORM

Ellen White's personal experience is particularly useful because it demonstrates that she did not teach health reform as a rigid system disconnected from actual circumstances. She described periods when she was compelled by circumstances to eat foods she would not ordinarily choose, including meat when traveling or when adequate food was unavailable. She also explained that her own family did not all eat exactly the same foods and that she did not attempt to dictate their choices. The original Letter 127, 1904 demonstrates this very clearly. This is important because it prevents us from creating an artificial picture of health reform. She was a reformer. She practiced what she taught. But she was not a fanatic.

She explicitly defended her record: “I have been a faithful health reformer.”
"It is reported by some that I have not followed the principles of health reform as I have advocated them with my pen; but I can say that I have been a faithful health reformer. Those who have been members of my family know that this is true." - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 9, p. 159

That testimony should be read alongside her warnings against making personal practice into a universal criterion.

9.11 - HEALTH REFORM SHOULD INCREASE OUR USEFULNESS

The final measure of health reform is not: How many foods have I eliminated? Nor: How strict is my diet compared with someone else? The greater question is: Am I becoming more useful in the service of God? If health reform gives us greater strength to work- Praise God. If it gives us greater mental clarity to study- Praise God. If it gives us greater self-control- Praise God. If it enables us to minister more effectively to the sick- Praise God. If it helps us live more temperately and represent Christ more faithfully- Praise God. That is the proper fruit of health reform.

THE #7-9 PRINCIPLES IN SUMMARY

We can now see how Principles 7-9 complete the first six principles.

PRINCIPLE 7 — CLEANLINESS AND PROPER CARE OF THE BODY

The body must be cared for through cleanliness, proper hygiene, pure air, water, exercise, rest, wholesome food, and intelligent attention to individual needs. Biblical foundation:
“Know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost?” 1 Corinthians 6:19

PRINCIPLE 8 — THE CONNECTION BETWEEN PHYSICAL HABITS AND THE MIND

The condition of the body can influence the mind, judgment, self-control, and capacity for spiritual service. Therefore, appetite and physical habits must be brought under the government of reason and the Holy Spirit. Biblical foundation:
“And every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things.” 1 Corinthians 9:25

PRINCIPLE 9 — HEALTH REFORM AS PREPARATION FOR GREATER SPIRITUAL SERVICE

The purpose of health reform is not merely physical longevity. It is to preserve and strengthen the faculties God has given us so that we may glorify Him, serve others, proclaim the gospel, and prepare for the coming of Christ. Biblical foundation:
“Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Corinthians 10:31

THE BALANCED PICTURE OF HEALTH REFORM

The nine principles now form a coherent progression:

1. TEMPERANCE - I must govern myself.
2. WHOLESOME FOOD - I must nourish the body properly.
3. AVOID HARMFUL SUBSTANCES - I must protect the body and mind from that which injures or enslaves.
4. PROPER PREPARATION AND MODERATION - I must learn how to use good things wisely.
5. REST, EXERCISE, FRESH AIR, AND REGULARITY - I must care for the whole physical organism.
6. SELF-CONTROL OVER APPETITE AND PASSION - My desires must remain under principle.
7. CLEANLINESS AND PROPER CARE - I must respect the body God has entrusted to me.
8. BODY AND MIND - My physical habits affect my mental and spiritual capacity.
9. SPIRITUAL SERVICE - I preserve my health so that I may better glorify God and serve Him.

And this brings us back to the central principle established at the beginning: “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Corinthians 10:31

Health reform is therefore not an end in itself. It is a means of stewardship, service, self-government, and an aid to mental and spiritual clarity. It is an avenue for missionary work. And properly understood, it is the right arm of the gospel, but not the gospel itself. The danger is therefore found at both extremes: Neglect health reform leads to disregard God's light. Exalt health reform above the gospel leads to distort God's light. The safe path is: “What saith the Lord?” “What is the principle?” “How does Scripture apply it?” “What is my individual responsibility before God?” “How can I practice and teach it in the spirit of Christ?” That is the path of genuine health reform. And it prepares us for the next section of the study, because whenever genuine reform is presented, Satan will seek either to make people reject it or to drive them into extremes.

Back to top ⇧

IV. PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH REFORM: 10-12

Principle 10 — Health Reform and Christian Character

Health reform is not merely a question of what we eat or drink. It is connected with self-control, temperance, moral character, and the development of the whole person. The purpose of health reform is not to create a people who are merely strict in diet, but a people whose physical habits cooperate with the work of God in the formation of Christian character.

“The health of the body is to be regarded as essential to growth in grace and the acquirement of an even temper. If the stomach is not properly cared for, the formation of an upright, moral character will be hindered. The brain and nerves are in sympathy with the stomach. Erroneous eating and drinking result in erroneous thinking and acting.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 9, p. 159-160 (also in RH, March 3, 1910)

This gives us an important principle: physical health and spiritual character are not unrelated subjects. The Christian does not care for the body merely to live longer or feel better. The body is an instrument of service to God.

1 Corinthians 6:19-20 “What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own? For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's.”

1 Corinthians 10:31 “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.”

Therefore, the proper question is not merely: “Is this food forbidden?” but: “Will this choice help me glorify God, preserve my usefulness, strengthen self-control, and keep my mind clear for His service?” This is the proper spirit of health reform.

Health reform must never become legalism

There is a great danger on both sides. One person may disregard health reform completely and make appetite his master. Another may take legitimate principles and turn them into a system of human rules, judging everybody according to his personal standard. Both extremes are wrong. The Christian standard is not another person's appetite, personal practice, or interpretation. The standard is God's Word rightly understood and faithfully applied. Sister White warned against allowing personal opinions to become a rule for others: “We cannot make ourselves a criterion for anyone else.”

“I make myself a criterion for no one else. There are things that I cannot eat without suffering great distress. I try to learn that which is best for me, and then saying nothing to any one, I partake of the things that I can eat, which often are simply two or three varieties that will not create a disturbance in the stomach.” - Letter 45, 1903 (CD 493)

“But the other members of my family do not eat the same things that I do. I do not hold myself up as a criterion for them. I leave each one to follow his own ideas as to what is best for him. I bind no one else's conscience by my own. One person cannot be a criterion for another in the matter of eating.” - Letter 127, 1904 (CD 491)

“We should not make others our criterion nor excuse anything in our course because others have done wrong. God has given us consciences for ourselves. Great principles have been laid down in His word, which are sufficient to guide us in our Christian walk and general deportment.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 3, p. 523

The practical lesson is important. A person may have learned through experience that a particular food does not agree with him. That does not automatically give him authority to declare that the same food is sinful for everyone else. Health reform requires knowledge, experience, self-control, humility, and Christian charity.

Principle 11 — Health Reform and Medical Missionary Work

Health reform was never intended to exist as an isolated dietary movement. It was designed to become an entering point for the gospel and a means of practical Christian service. Christ's method was comprehensive.

Matthew 9:35 “And Jesus went about all the cities and villages, teaching in their synagogues, and preaching the gospel of the kingdom, and healing every sickness and every disease among the people.”

The ministry of Christ united: teaching, preaching, healing, compassion, practical service, and spiritual restoration. This same principle should characterize Christian medical missionary work. Health reform therefore gives God's people an opportunity to meet people where they are and help them understand the relationship between their habits and their physical, mental, and spiritual condition. Health reform opens doors for the gospel

Health reform is closely connected with the gospel work:
“The work of health reform connected with the present truth for this time, is a power for good. It is the right hand of the gospel, and often opens fields for the entrance of the gospel.” - Manuscript 16, 1901, par. 16 (1SM 112)

This is an important distinction. The right hand is not the whole body. Health reform is a powerful agency of gospel work, but it must remain connected with the gospel itself. We should therefore avoid two errors:
Error #1: Neglect health reform altogether.
Error #2: Make health reform the entire message.
The biblical model is balance. Christ healed the sick, but He did not merely make people physically healthy. He called them to repentance, faith, obedience, and eternal life.

Medical missionary work must be practical Health reform should not merely consist of preaching against things. We should teach people what to do. Instead of simply saying: “Do not eat this.” we should also teach: “Here is what you can eat.” Instead of merely saying: “Do not drink harmful substances.” we should teach: “Here are wholesome alternatives.” Instead of merely condemning unhealthy habits, we should demonstrate: proper nutrition, simple cooking, cleanliness, exercise, rest, fresh air, temperance, water, self-control, and trust in God. This makes health reform a ministry rather than merely a controversy.

Health reform must meet people where they are. One of the most important safeguards against fanaticism is recognizing the actual condition of the people we are trying to help. People come from different: cultures, climates, occupations, economic circumstances, physical constitutions, habits, and levels of knowledge. Therefore, health education must be patient, intelligent, practical, and compassionate.

We are warned against harsh methods: “Habits that have been thought right for a lifetime are not to be changed by harsh or hasty measures.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 9, p. 159.

Therefore, health reform must be carefully presented and supported by example. This principle is especially important in medical missionary work. We are not called to win arguments. We are called to win souls.

Principle 12 — Health Reform United With the Third Angel's Message

Health reform must never be separated from the larger gospel commission and the special message God has entrusted to His people. Ellen White repeatedly emphasized the relationship between health reform and the third angel's message:

“The health reform, I was shown, is a part of the third angel's message, and is just as closely connected with it as are the arm and hand with the human body.” - Letter 57, 1896 (CD 75)

And we are guarded against misunderstanding:
“The health reform is closely connected with the work of the third message, yet it is not the message.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol.1, p. 559

Thus the relationship may be illustrated this way: The third angel's message is the body. Health reform is the arm and hand. The hand is important. The arm is important. But the hand is not the whole body. Likewise, health reform is important, but it must never displace: Christ, the everlasting gospel, the commandments of God, the faith of Jesus, the sanctuary truth, the Sabbath, the judgment, and the final call to worship the Creator.

Health reform must serve the gospel

This is where the subject of tests becomes important.

“We are not to make the use of flesh food a test of fellowship.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 9, p. 159

This does not mean that flesh eating is equally desirable with a wholesome plant-based diet wherever the latter is readily available. The same passage says that we should consider the influence of professed believers who use flesh foods and asks whether God's messengers should disregard the light given on the subject. Therefore we must distinguish between: A principle and a test of fellowship. Something can be important counsel without becoming a church test. That distinction is essential.

The Sabbath Is a Biblical Test-Not Human Dietary Rules

This distinction becomes especially important when we consider the third angel's message.

“The question whether we shall eat butter, meat, or cheese, is not to be presented to any one as a test, but we are to educate and to show the evils of the things that are objectionable. Those who gather up these things and drive them upon others, do not know what work they are doing. The Word of God has given tests to His people. The keeping of God's holy law, the Sabbath, is a test, a sign between God and His people throughout their generations forever.” - Manuscript 5, 1881 (3SM 287)

This gives us a vital safeguard. We must never substitute human tests for God's tests.
Isaiah 8:20 “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.”

The Sabbath is explicitly identified in Scripture as a sign:
Exodus 31:16-17 “Wherefore the children of Israel shall keep the sabbath, to observe the sabbath throughout their generations, for a perpetual covenant. It is a sign between me and the children of Israel for ever.”

And Revelation's final message centers upon worship and obedience to the Creator:
Revelation 14:6-7 “Fear God, and give glory to him; for the hour of his judgment is come: and worship him that made heaven, and earth, and the sea, and the fountains of waters."
Therefore, health reform must support the third angel's message, not replace it.

Health Reform Is Not a License for Indulgence

While we must reject fanaticism, we must equally reject the opposite error of using the absence of a dietary test as an excuse for careless living. Sister White's statement that flesh food is not a test of fellowship does not mean: “Therefore diet does not matter.” Quite the contrary. She repeatedly called God's people to reform.

In 1909 she wrote:
“We do not mark out any precise line to be followed in diet; but we do say that in countries where there are fruits, grains, and nuts in abundance, flesh meat is not the right food for God's people.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 9, p. 159 (Also in RH, March 3, 1910)
And she immediately connected this with Christian character:
“The health of the body is to be regarded as essential to growth in grace and the acquirement of an even temper.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 9, p. 159

Thus there is no contradiction between saying: “Meat eating is not a test of fellowship,” and saying: “God's people should progressively advance in health reform.” The first guards against fanaticism. The second guards against carelessness. Both principles must be retained.

Do Not Make Diet the Measure of Salvation

One of the most dangerous distortions of health reform is the teaching that a person's salvation can be determined by whether he eats a particular food. This is not the biblical gospel.

The Bible defines sin:
1 John 3:4 “Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law.”

We must therefore be careful not to take something that Ellen White specifically said was not to be made a test of fellowship and turn it into a condition of salvation. Salvation is through Christ.

Ephesians 2:8-9 “For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast.”

But grace does not eliminate obedience.
Ephesians 2:10 “For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.”

Therefore, health reform belongs within the Christian life of sanctification, obedience, self-control, and preparation for service. It must never become a substitute for justification by faith in Christ.

A Necessary Distinction: Principle Versus Personal Application

This is one of the most important lessons from Ellen White's health counsel. There are broad principles that apply to all:

• temperance,
• self-control,
• avoiding intoxicating and narcotic substances,
• avoiding gluttony,
• seeking wholesome food,
• caring for the body,
• obtaining proper rest and exercise,
• and seeking to preserve health for God's service.

But the personal application of these principles may vary.

Ellen White stated: “We do not mark out any precise line to be followed in diet.” Yet she also gave definite counsel concerning the superiority of wholesome foods and the dangers of flesh eating. This prevents us from falling into either extreme.

Extreme #1: “Nothing matters.” Wrong.
Extreme #2: “My personal diet is God's universal law for everyone.” Also wrong.

The correct approach is: Study the principles. Understand the circumstances. Educate the conscience. Practice the light received. Do not bind another person's conscience to your personal standard.

Christ Must Remain the Center. This is ultimately where the entire subject must lead. Health reform is not designed to make us proud of our diet. It is designed to make us more useful to God. It is not designed to make us condemn others. It is designed to teach us self-government. It is not designed to make food the center of our religion. It is designed to help keep the mind clear so that Christ may remain the center of our religion. Paul gives the governing principle:

Philippians 4:5 “Let your moderation be known unto all men. The Lord is at hand.”

1 Corinthians 9:25 “And every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things.”

The goal is therefore not merely a healthier body. The goal is a temperate Christian character, a clearer mind, greater usefulness in God's service, and a life that brings glory to Him.

Biblical health reform requires neither careless indulgence nor fanatical restriction. It requires intelligent obedience to God's principles, exercised with self-control, humility, Christian charity, and a constant recognition that Christ and His gospel-not diet-are the center of the third angel's message.

Back to top ⇧

V. RESULTS OF FANATICISM

When Reform Loses Its Biblical Balance

Health reform is a blessing when it is understood and practiced according to the principles of Scripture. But even a good reform can become a source of harm when human opinions are elevated above God's Word, when personal convictions are imposed upon others, or when physical reform is separated from the gospel.

We are repeatedly warned that fanaticism can arise among those who profess to believe present truth. The danger is not merely that people may adopt unusual practices. The deeper danger is that human ideas may be presented as divine requirements, consciences may be bound where God has not bound them, and the attention of God's people may be diverted from Christ and His Word.

"Fanaticism, once started and left unchecked, is as hard to quench as a fire which has obtained hold of a building. Those who have entered into and sustained this fanaticism, might far better be engaged in secular labor; for by their inconsistent course of action they are dishonoring the Lord and imperiling His people. Many such movements will arise at this time, when the Lord’s work should stand elevated, pure, unadulterated with superstition and fables. We need to be on our guard, to maintain a close connection with Christ, that we be not deceived by Satan’s devices." - General Conference Bulletin, April 23, 1901 (2SM 35)

This warning provides an important principle for understanding health reform: The answer to fanaticism is not rejection of reform, but a return to the biblical principles upon which true reform rests.

1. WHAT IS FANATICISM?

Fanaticism is an unbalanced, unreasonable, or extreme religious zeal that goes beyond the Word of God and often attempts to make human ideas matters of conscience. It may appear very religious. It may speak constantly about holiness, reform, obedience, health, prophecy, or present truth. Yet religious language alone does not make an idea biblical. The test is: What saith the Word of God? There is danger of allowing impressions, excitement, and human ideas to take the place of Scripture:

“We must direct the minds of the people to the Word as the foundation of our faith... Any manifestation of fanaticism takes the mind away from the evidence of truth—the Word itself.” - Manuscript 115, 1908 (2SM 42)

This is an essential principle in health reform. If a person takes one statement about diet and builds an entire system around it, while ignoring the broader principles of Scripture and the complete counsel of the Spirit of Prophecy, that person is not necessarily demonstrating greater faithfulness. He may actually be moving away from the balanced principles of true reform.

2. WHEN REFORM BECOMES AN EXTREME

There is a difference between reform and extremism. True reform brings the life into greater harmony with God's principles. Extremism takes one principle beyond its proper place and makes it the controlling principle of everything.

“The reforms that are strained to the highest tension might accommodate a certain class... but this class forms a very small minority of the people to whom these tests seem unnecessary... Thus health reform is brought to disrepute. The work we have tried to build up solidly is confused with strange things that God has not required.” - Letter 37, 1901 (CD 206)

This is an important distinction. God's reform must never be confused with man's extremes. A person may begin with a legitimate concern about diet and gradually move into rigid rules that God Himself has never established. The result is often not greater holiness but confusion, discouragement, division, and distrust.

3. MAKING HEALTH REFORM THE WHOLE MESSAGE

One of the greatest dangers is allowing health reform to become the message instead of an important part of the work connected with the message. Health reform has an important place. It is closely connected with the third angel's message and is valuable in preparing people for greater service to God. But it must remain in its proper relationship to the gospel. The health message does not replace: justification by faith; Christ and His righteousness; the commandments of God; the Sabbath; the testimony of Jesus; the sanctuary; the three angels' messages; the call to repentance and conversion. When health reform is presented as though it were the entire foundation of Christianity, the centrality of Christ is obscured. We are warned that Satan would seek to divert minds from the third angel's message through extremes:

“He [Satan] is working with all his insinuating, deceiving power, to lead men away from the third angel’s message, which is to be proclaimed with mighty power. If Satan sees that the Lord is blessing His people and preparing them to discern his delusions, he will work with his master power to bring in fanaticism on the one hand and cold formalism on the other, that he may gather in a harvest of souls. Now is our time to watch unceasingly. Watch, bar the way to the least step of advance that Satan may make among you.” - Manuscript 16, 1890 (2SM 19)

Thus, health reform must serve the gospel, not eclipse the gospel.

4. JUDGING OTHERS BY PERSONAL STANDARDS

One of the clearest manifestations of fanaticism is making oneself the standard for everyone else. A person discovers that a certain food, meal schedule, preparation method, or lifestyle works well for himself. He then assumes that everyone else must follow precisely the same practice. But human constitutions differ.

"There is a wide difference in constitutions and temperaments, and the demands of the system differ greatly in different persons. What would be food for one, might be poison for another; so precise rules cannot be laid down to fit every case. I cannot eat beans, for they are poison to me; but for me to say that for this reason no one must eat them would be simply ridiculous. I cannot eat a spoonful of milk gravy, or milk toast, without suffering in consequence; but other members of my family can eat these things, and realize no such effect; therefore I take that which suits my stomach best, and they do the same. We have no words, no contention; all moves along harmoniously in my large family, for I do not attempt to dictate what they shall or shall not eat." - Letter 19a, 1891 (CD 494)

"But the other members of my family do not eat the same things that I do. I do not hold myself up as a criterion for them. I leave each one to follow his own ideas as to what is best for him. I bind no one else’s conscience by my own. One person cannot be a criterion for another in the matter of eating. It is impossible to make one rule for all to follow. There are those in my family who are very fond of beans, while to me beans are poison. Butter is never placed on my table, but if the members of my family choose to use a little butter away from the table, they are at liberty to do so. Our table is set twice a day, but if there are those who desire something to eat in the evening, there is no rule that forbids them from getting it. No one complains or goes from our table dissatisfied. A variety of food that is simple, wholesome, and palatable, is always provided." - Letter 127, 1904 (CD 491)

This does not mean that there are no health principles. There are. It means that principles must not be confused with man-made applications.

For example, temperance is a principle. But a person's exact quantity of food, meal schedule, exercise requirement, or response to particular foods may vary. Therefore, we should teach principles while allowing individuals to prayerfully apply those principles according to their circumstances, constitution, occupation, climate, and needs.

5. FORCING CONSCIENCE

True Christian reform appeals to the conscience; fanaticism attempts to control the conscience. There is an enormous difference between saying: “Here is the light God has given. Let us study it and follow it.” and saying: “You must follow my exact interpretation, or you are disobedient to God.” The latter approach is dangerous because it places human authority where God alone has authority. We are warned against making diet a test:

“The enemy of our work is pleased when a subject of minor importance can be used to divert the minds of our brethren from the great questions that should be the burden of our message. As this is not a test question, I entreat of my brethren that they shall not allow the enemy to triumph by having it treated as such.” - Manuscript 11, 1910 (1SM 164)

This principle should govern our teaching. We may teach God's counsel without becoming masters of another person's conscience.

6. CREATING RULES WHERE GOD HAS NOT SPOKEN

Fanaticism frequently begins when people take a legitimate principle and create additional rules that God has not given. The danger is especially serious when these additional rules are presented with the words: “The Lord says...” when the Lord has not actually said them. Ellen White warned about this broader problem:

“This class urged upon the people human tests and manufactured crosses, which Christ had not given them to bear... - RH November 20, 1883 (2SM 27)

This principle applies directly to health reform. We should distinguish between: What Scripture clearly teaches and What Ellen White counsels as health instruction and What is merely an individual's personal application. These three categories should never be confused. A personal conviction may be precious to the individual who holds it, but that does not automatically make it a universal test for God's people.

7. NEGLECTING THE GOSPEL WHILE EMPHASIZING PHYSICAL REFORM

A person can become so occupied with food, exercise, natural remedies, preparation methods, and physical health that the spiritual health of the soul is neglected. This is a serious danger. A person may know: what foods to eat, what foods not to eat, how many meals to eat, how much water to drink, how to exercise, how to prepare food, and yet know little about: repentance; faith; prayer; surrender; self-denial; forgiveness; love; obedience; Christ's righteousness. That would be a tragic imbalance. Physical health is important, but physical reform is not a substitute for conversion.

Paul wrote:
“For bodily exercise profiteth little: but godliness is profitable unto all things, having promise of the life that now is, and of that which is to come.” 1 Timothy 4:8

The Christian therefore seeks both physical temperance and spiritual godliness.

8. THE DANGER OF EXTREMES IN DIET

Extreme dietary practices can actually undermine the purpose of health reform.

“Those who have but a partial understanding of the principles of reform are often the most rigid, not only in carrying out their views themselves, but in urging them on their families and their neighbors.” She explained that such mistaken reforms can result in poor health and can cause others to reject health reform altogether. - Ministry of Healing, p. 318

This is why health reform must be understood intelligently. A person may eliminate one food but fail to replace its nutritional value. A person may become so restrictive that the body is inadequately nourished. A person may reject foods that others can use without difficulty. A person may adopt a diet unsuitable for his particular occupation or circumstances. And then the resulting weakness is blamed upon health reform itself. That is not true reform. Health reform should promote health-not destroy it.

9. FANATICISM CAN DESTROY THE INFLUENCE OF TRUTH

Fanaticism does not remain a private matter. It affects families, churches, ministries, and the reputation of the truth before the world.

“There are persons of an excitable temperament who are easily led into fanaticism; and should we allow anything to come into our churches that would lead such persons into error, we would soon see these errors carried to extreme lengths; and then because of the course of these disorderly elements a stigma would rest upon *the whole body of Seventh-day Adventists*.” - Manuscript 115, 1908 (2SM 43)

This is why the church cannot treat fanaticism lightly. A person may say: “It is only my personal conviction.” But if that conviction is continually imposed upon others, produces division, or is presented as a divine test, it becomes more than a personal conviction. It becomes a source of confusion.

NOTE: For more info, the SDA Church of today has fallen

10. FANATICISM CAN TURN PEOPLE AWAY FROM THE TRUTH

One of Ellen White's strongest warnings is that fanaticism can actually make the truth appear repulsive to sincere people. She wrote:

“You might take a consistent course, but those who would be influenced by you might take a very inconsistent course, and, as a result, we should very soon have our hands full of something that would make it almost impossible to give unbelievers the right impression of our message and work.” Her solution was simple: “We must go to the people with the solid Word of God.” - Manuscript 115, 1908 (2SM 43)

This is especially important in health evangelism. If an unbeliever meets a Christian who is constantly condemning others over food, imposing rigid rules, arguing about minor details, and treating personal dietary practices as salvation issues, the person may reject not merely the fanatic-but the truth that the fanatic claims to represent. Thus: Fanaticism does evangelistic damage.

11. FANATICISM DIVERTS THE MIND FROM THE WORD OF GOD

The Bible must remain the foundation of every genuine reform. The Testimonies repeatedly connected fanaticism with a departure from the Word.

“Any manifestation of fanaticism takes the mind away from the evidence of truth—the Word itself.” - Manuscript 115, 1908 (2SM 42)

This gives us an important test. When a health teaching causes people to spend more time arguing about food than studying Scripture, something has gone wrong. When a particular diet becomes more important than Christ, something has gone wrong. When people know every quotation about diet but neglect the commandments of God, something has gone wrong. When a person can explain what everybody else should eat but cannot demonstrate the fruits of the Spirit, something has gone wrong. The purpose of reform is not to make us experts in condemning others. The purpose of reform is to make us better servants of God.

12. FANATICISM PRODUCES DISORDER AND EXCITEMENT

Fanaticism often feeds upon excitement. We are warned concerning fanatical religious movements:

"The Lord desires to have in His service order and discipline, not excitement and confusion. We are not now able to describe with accuracy the scenes to be enacted in our world in the future; but this we do know, that this is a time when we must watch unto prayer; for the great day of the Lord is at hand. Satan is rallying his forces. We need to be thoughtful and still, and to contemplate the truths of revelation. Excitement is not favorable to growth in grace, to true purity and sanctification of the spirit." - General Conference Bulletin, April 23, 1901 (2SM 35)

This principle applies beyond worship services. It applies to health teaching as well. True reform is usually: thoughtful; orderly; patient; practical; teachable; Christ-centered; founded upon Scripture. Fanaticism tends to be: urgent; rigid; sensational; argumentative; suspicious; divisive; intolerant of legitimate differences. The difference is not necessarily in how strongly a person believes. It is in how that belief is governed by God's Word and Christian character.

13. FANATICISM CAN PRODUCE DIVISION

Fanaticism can produce: broken friendships; divided families; church factions; distrust of leadership; rejection of counsel; independent movements; suspicion of fellow believers; loss of Christian charity.

We are warned that independent, self-directed movements could bring confusion and division among believers. The Christian should therefore ask: Is my reform making me more Christlike, or more combative? If a person's reform makes him increasingly: harsh, critical, suspicious, impatient, judgmental, divisive, then something is wrong with the way the reform is being understood or practiced.

14. FANATICISM CAN REPLACE CHRIST WITH HUMAN IDEAS

The deepest danger of fanaticism is not merely dietary extremism. It is displacement of Christ. A person may begin with a sincere desire to honor God and eventually become absorbed in his own system. His confidence gradually shifts: from Christ leads to his interpretation; from Scripture leads to his rules; from faith leads to his performance; from Christian charity leads to judgment of others. That is not spiritual victory. Christ must remain the center.

“Looking unto Jesus the author and finisher of our faith.” Hebrews 12:2

The Christian reformer must therefore continually ask: Am I becoming more like Christ through this reform? If not, the reform has lost its proper purpose.

15. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TRUE REFORM AND FANATICISM

The distinction can be summarized as follows:

This is the balance that must govern the entire study.

16. HEALTH REFORM MUST PRODUCE CHRISTIAN CHARACTER

It is to help produce people who are better prepared to serve God. The proper question is therefore not merely: “What am I eating?” but also: “What kind of person am I becoming?” Am I becoming: more patient? more self-controlled? more useful? more temperate? more humble? more compassionate? more disciplined? more spiritually minded? more willing to serve? more Christlike?

Paul gives the governing principle:
“Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Corinthians 10:31

Health reform must therefore be brought under the greater principle of living for the glory of God.

17. THE NEED FOR BALANCE, HUMILITY, AND CHRISTIAN CHARITY

The answer to fanaticism is not indifference. Nor is the answer to fanaticism rejection of health reform. The answer is biblical balance. We should teach the principles God has given. We should practice what we teach. We should encourage people to make needed changes. We should demonstrate the blessings of temperance. We should educate rather than condemn. We should distinguish God's requirements from personal preferences. We should recognize differences in constitution and circumstances. And we should never make ourselves the conscience of another person.

“We must bring our minds within the bounds of reason, lest the enemy so come in as to set everything in a disorderly way.” - Manuscript 115, 1908 (2SM 43)

The Spirit of God does not lead God's people away from Scripture, reason, Christian charity, and self-control.

REFORM WITHOUT FANATICISM

Health reform is God's blessing when it is kept in its proper place. It is not to be despised. It is not to be neglected. But neither is it to be exaggerated. We must not turn a principle into a test God has not made. We must not turn personal conviction into universal law. We must not turn diet into the gospel. We must not turn health instruction into a weapon against our brethren. And we must not allow legitimate reform to become so extreme that people are driven away from the very truth we are seeking to proclaim. The genuine health reformer should be able to say with Paul:

“For the kingdom of God is not meat and drink; but righteousness, and peace, and joy in the Holy Ghost.” Romans 14:17

“Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Corinthians 10:31

The goal is therefore not merely healthier bodies, but sanctified lives prepared for God's service. True reform brings the life into harmony with God's principles. Fanaticism takes God's principles beyond their proper boundaries and replaces divine wisdom with human judgment. Let us therefore hold fast to the truth without adding to it, practice reform without making it a weapon, teach without forcing, correct without condemning, and above all keep Jesus Christ at the centre of every reform.

“We need to be on our guard, to maintain a close connection with Christ, that we be not deceived by Satan’s devices.” - General Conference Bulletin, April 23, 1901 (2SM 35)

The safeguard against fanaticism is not less consecration, but consecration governed by the Word of God, centered in Christ, and manifested in humility, reason, self-control, and love.

Back to top ⇧

VI. TEMPERANCE AND THE SUNDAY MOVEMENT

A False Unity Foretold

The work of temperance is, in itself, a good and important work. The Bible repeatedly calls God's people to self-control, sobriety, moderation, and separation from destructive habits.

“And every man that striveth for the mastery is temperate in all things.” 1 Corinthians 9:25

“Let your moderation be known unto all men. The Lord is at hand.” Philippians 4:5

“Be sober, be vigilant; because your adversary the devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour.” 1 Peter 5:8

Therefore, Christians should not oppose genuine temperance. The danger arises when a good moral reform becomes joined with a religious movement that seeks to establish Sunday observance by civil authority.

"Yet this very class put forth the claim that the fast-spreading corruption is largely attributable to the desecration of the so-called “Christian Sabbath,” and that the enforcement of Sunday observance would greatly improve the morals of society. Combining the temperance reform with the Sunday movement, they represent themselves as laboring to promote the highest interests of society; and those who refuse to unite with them are denounced as the enemies of temperance and reform. But the fact that a movement to establish error is connected with a work which is in itself good, is not an argument in favor of the error. We may disguise poison by mingling it with wholesome food, but we do not thereby change its nature. On the contrary, it is rendered more dangerous, as it is more likely to be taken unawares. It is one of Satan’s devices to combine with falsehood just enough truth to give it plausibility. The leaders of the Sunday movement may advocate reforms which the people need, principles which are in harmony with the Bible, yet while there is with these a requirement which is contrary to God’s law, his servants cannot unite with them. Nothing can justify them in setting aside the commandments of God for the precepts of men." - Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 4, p. 404.1

The Spirit of Prophecy warned that Temperance and Sunday reform would be joined together in such a way that those who refused to participate could be portrayed as enemies of morality and reform. The Sunday movement could advocate reforms that were genuinely needed and principles that were harmonious with Scripture, yet at the same time introduce a requirement contrary to God's law. God's people were not to unite with that requirement. The principle is clear: A good cause does not make an erroneous religious requirement good merely because the two have been joined together.

It also illustrated the danger by comparing truth mixed with error to wholesome food mixed with poison. The wholesome food does not change the nature of the poison; instead, the mixture makes the poison more difficult to detect.

The principle

The issue is therefore not: “Is temperance good?” It certainly is. The issue is: “Can God's people unite with a movement that combines legitimate moral reform with a religious requirement contrary to God's law?” The answer is No.

1. SATAN'S METHOD: MIXING TRUTH WITH ERROR

One of Satan's most effective methods is not to present error in its naked form. Instead, he combines:

• truth + error
• good reform + false doctrine
• legitimate morality + religious coercion
• social improvement + violation of conscience

The truth makes the error appear respectable. This is precisely why the Sunday movement can become dangerous. A person may hear: temperance, family values, morality, rest, social order, concern for the poor, protection of society, religious values, and conclude that every part of the movement must therefore be good. But God's people must examine the entire movement by the Word of God. The question is not merely: “Is this particular reform good?” The question is: “What else is being joined to this reform?” If obedience to a man-made religious institution is included, God's people cannot accept the package simply because some portions of it are beneficial.

2. TEMPERANCE MUST NEVER BECOME A SUBSTITUTE FOR OBEDIENCE TO GOD

True temperance is biblical. But temperance does not give human beings authority to change God's law.

The fourth commandment says:
“Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.” Exodus 20:8

And the commandment specifically identifies the seventh day:
“The seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God.” Exodus 20:10

Therefore, no amount of moral reform can authorize a change in God's commandment. This is where the controversy becomes much deeper than the question of which day people prefer to rest. The issue is: Who has authority over the conscience-God or man?

Jesus said:
“But in vain they do worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.” Matthew 15:9

3. THE SUNDAY MOVEMENT CAN PRESENT A MORAL ARGUMENT

The Spirit of Prophecy specifically warned that the Sunday movement would not necessarily appear as an openly anti-Christian movement. Its advocates could present arguments concerning the welfare of society. They could support reforms that were genuinely needed. They could appeal to the moral condition of the nation. They could point to social disorder and claim that Sunday observance would help restore morality. This is precisely what makes the deception dangerous. The Spirit of Prophecy described the argument that enforcement of Sunday observance would improve the morals of society connected with the temperance work and warned that God's people could not unite with the Sunday requirement when it violated God's law.

“Men in responsible positions will not only ignore and despise the Sabbath themselves, but from the sacred desk, will urge upon the people the observance of the first day of the week, pleading tradition and custom in behalf of this man-made institution. They will point to calamities on land and sea—to the storms of wind, the floods, the earthquakes, the destruction by fire—as judgments indicating God’s displeasure because Sunday is not sacredly observed. These calamities will increase more and more, one disaster will follow close upon the heels of another; and those who make void the law of God will point to the few who are keeping the Sabbath of the fourth commandment as the ones who are bringing wrath upon the world. This falsehood is Satan’s device that he may ensnare the unwary.” - ST January 17, 1884, par. 12

Thus, the final issue will not necessarily be presented as: “Choose God or Satan.” It may initially appear as: “Choose morality or immorality.” “Choose temperance or intemperance.” “Choose family values or social corruption.” “Choose a day of rest or social chaos.” But beneath these arguments is a deeper question: Will human legislation be permitted to establish a religious requirement that God has not commanded?

4. THE SABBATH WILL BECOME THE GREAT TEST

This distinction is essential. Temperance is important. Health reform is important. Moral reform is important. But the final controversy over worship centers upon obedience to God's commandments.

“The keeping of God's holy law, the Sabbath, is a test, a sign between God and His people throughout their generations forever. Forever this is the burden of the third angel’s message—the commandments of God and the testimony of Jesus Christ.” - Manuscript 5, 1881 (3SM 287)

This harmonizes with Revelation:
“Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.” Revelation 14:12

The issue is therefore not whether God's people believe in temperance. They should. It is not whether they support legitimate moral reform. They should. The issue is whether they will surrender obedience to God's law in order to cooperate with a religious movement that establishes human requirements.

5. THE WARNING GIVEN TO GOD'S PEOPLE

The Spirit of Prophecy's warning concerning Sunday legislation is remarkably specific.

“There is need of Sabbath reform among us, who profess to observe God's holy rest day.... The Lord has a controversy with his professed people in these last days. In this controversy men in responsible positions will take a course directly opposite to that pursued by Nehemiah. They will not only ignore and despise the Sabbath themselves, but they will try to keep it from others by burying it beneath the rubbish of custom and tradition. In churches and in large gatherings in the open air, ministers will urge upon the people the necessity of keeping the first day of the week.” - RH March 18, 1884, par. 7-8

Notice the setting. This would not merely be an atheistic attack upon Christianity. It would involve: churches, ministers, religious gatherings, tradition, custom, and Sunday observance. The controversy would therefore involve religious authority.

6. RELIGIOUS LEADERS WILL APPEAL TO CALAMITIES

The same prophecy continues with another significant feature that calamities would be used as an argument for Sunday observance. Disasters would be interpreted as evidence of God's displeasure because Sunday was not being observed, while Sabbathkeepers would be accused of bringing God's wrath upon the world.

“There are calamities on sea and land: and these calamities will increase, one disaster following close upon another;...” - RH March 18, 1884, par. 8

This is important because it reveals the method of persuasion. The argument will not necessarily be: “We want to disobey God.” Rather: “Society is suffering.” “Something must be done.” “God is judging the nation.” “We need to return to religious morality.” “Everyone must unite.” The pressure will therefore be presented as a solution to a perceived crisis. But God's people must remember: A crisis does not give man permission to alter God's law.

7. THE FALSE ACCUSATION AGAINST SABBATHKEEPERS

The Spirit of Prophecy continues:

“... the little band of conscientious Sabbath-keepers will be pointed out as the ones who are bringing the wrath of God upon the world by their disregard of Sunday.” - RH March 18, 1884, par. 8

This is a remarkable reversal. Those who are actually seeking to obey God's commandment will be accused of being the cause of the world's problems. Those who demand obedience to a man-made religious requirement will claim to be defending society. This is why the final conflict cannot be understood merely as a debate about calendars. It is a conflict over worship, authority, law, and conscience.

8. CHURCH AND STATE WILL UNITE

Immediately following this warning, the Spirit of Prophecy described the deeper principle:

“... Church and State will be united in the same corrupt harmony.” - RH March 18, 1884, par. 10

This is the critical danger. The church has authority in spiritual matters. Civil government has authority in civil matters. When religious leaders seek to use the civil power to enforce religious observance, the separation between religious authority and civil authority is compromised. The result is religious coercion. The Bible gives a prophetic picture of this type of union in Revelation 13. The beast power receives authority, and the second beast exercises its influence in behalf of the first.

“And he exerciseth all the power of the first beast before him...” Revelation 13:12

And ultimately:

“And he causeth all, both small and great, rich and poor, free and bond, to receive a mark...” Revelation 13:16

The final controversy therefore concerns forced worship versus obedience to God.

9. WHAT SHOULD GOD'S PEOPLE DO?

The answer is not to oppose every temperance organization. Nor should God's people oppose every social reform merely because Sundaykeepers participate in it. That would itself be an extreme. Instead, we must distinguish between: Genuine temperance and Religious Sunday enforcement. We can teach: abstinence from intoxicating substances; self-control; wholesome living; proper nutrition; care of the body; family responsibility; moral purity; compassion for the suffering. But when a movement requires acceptance of Sunday as a religious obligation, God's people must stand upon principle.

The counsel is unmistakable:
“Nothing can justify them in setting aside the commandments of God for the precepts of men.”- Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 4, p. 404.1

That principle is supported by Christ Himself: “Howbeit in vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.” Mark 7:7

10. WE MUST NOT CONFUSE COOPERATION WITH COMPROMISE

There is an important distinction here. Christians can work with others on matters that are genuinely moral and humanitarian without surrendering biblical truth. For example, we can support: temperance; prevention of substance abuse; protection of children; care for the poor; disaster relief; health education; opposition to violence; protection of human life. But cooperation must have boundaries. We cannot say: “Because this organization does some good things, therefore everything it teaches must be accepted.” Neither can we say: “Because we agree with temperance, therefore we must accept Sunday legislation.” That is precisely the deception we are warned about.

11. THE TEST IS GOD'S LAW

What, then, is the final standard? Not: popular opinion; political parties; religious leaders; public sentiment; social pressure; majority vote; denominational prestige; health reform; temperance organizations.

The standard is:
“To the law and to the testimony.” - Isaiah 8:20

And the final message declares:
“Fear God, and give glory to him; for the hour of his judgment is come.” - Revelation 14:7

Then:
“Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.” - Revelation 14:12

This is the proper relationship between health reform, temperance, and the third angel's message. Health reform prepares the body for service. Temperance develops self-control. The gospel transforms the heart. The law reveals God's standard. The Sabbath identifies the Creator. The three angels' messages call the world to worship the Creator and reject the counterfeit.

12. A WARNING AGAINST FALSE UNITY

The great danger is false unity. True Christian unity is built upon truth.

Jesus prayed: “Sanctify them through thy truth: thy word is truth.” John 17:17

Therefore, unity cannot be achieved by setting aside God's commandments. The cry: “Let us all unite for the good of society” sounds beautiful. But if the proposed unity requires obedience to a commandment of men instead of obedience to God, it becomes a false unity. The apostles faced the same principle when commanded by human authorities to stop preaching. Their answer was: “We ought to obey God rather than men.” Acts 5:29. That principle will again become decisive.

13. THE RELATIONSHIP TO HEALTH REFORM

This brings us back to the subject of our study. Why would a study on health reform discuss the Sunday movement? Because the Spirit of Prophecy warned that temperance reform could become connected with Sunday observance. This does not make temperance evil. It makes it necessary for God's people to understand the difference between: the reform itself and the religious movement that may use the reform for another purpose. This is exactly why the principles of health reform must be understood correctly. If health reform becomes fanatical, it can become a tool that drives people away. If health reform becomes political, it can become entangled with worldly power. If health reform becomes the whole message, it eclipses Christ. But when health reform remains in its proper place, it becomes a valuable right arm of the gospel.

14. THE FINAL ISSUE: WHOM WILL WE OBEY?

The final question is not merely: What shall we eat? Nor: Which reform movement shall we join? Nor: Which religious leader shall we follow? The ultimate question is: Whom shall we obey?

Joshua declared:
“Choose you this day whom ye will serve.” Joshua 24:15

The three angels' messages likewise call humanity to choose whom they will worship.
“Fear God, and give glory to him.” Revelation 14:7

The counterfeit calls for worship according to human authority. God calls for worship according to His Word. The issue of the Sabbath therefore becomes the great test because it is a direct question of divine authority versus human authority.

STAND FOR TRUTH WITHOUT OPPOSING TRUE REFORM

We should therefore be temperate. We should promote health. We should practice self-control. We should support legitimate moral reform. We should help those struggling with destructive habits. We should be a blessing to society. But we must never allow a good reform to become the vehicle for a false religious requirement. We must never exchange God's commandments for human traditions. We must never sacrifice conscience for the sake of popularity. And we must never permit the desire for unity to lead us into disobedience. The principle is simple: Accept the good. Reject the error. Hold fast to God's law. The temperance movement may contain much that is good. The health reform movement contains much that is good. Social reform may contain much that is good. But when any movement demands that God's commandments be set aside for human requirements, the Christian's duty is settled: “We ought to obey God rather than men.” Acts 5:29. And when the final conflict comes, God's people will be identified not by their political alliances, not by their popularity, and not merely by their health practices, but by their loyalty to God: “Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.” Revelation 14:12.

Back to top ⇧

VI. HOW SHALL WE GUARD THE CHURCH AGAINST FANATICISM?

Fanaticism is not overcome by neglecting truth, lowering the standard, or becoming indifferent to error. Neither is it overcome by replacing one extreme with another. The remedy is a return to the Word of God, Gospel order, sound judgment, Christian humility, and the complete message for this time. The Spirit of Prophecy repeatedly warned that fanaticism would arise among God's professed people, particularly as the work approaches its close. The danger is not merely that individuals may become fanatical. Fanaticism can weaken families, divide churches, discredit the message, confuse sincere souls, and divert attention from the great work of preparing the world for the coming of Christ. Therefore, God's people must know how to recognize it, how to resist it, and how to deal with it in a biblical and Christlike manner.

1. DEFEND THE TRUTH FROM FANATICAL ATTACKS

The answer to fanaticism is not silence. God's servants must defend the truth with the Word of God.

“Fearlessly did Luther defend the gospel from the attacks which came from every quarter. The word of God proved itself a weapon mighty in every conflict. With that word he warred against the usurped authority of the pope, and the rationalistic philosophy of the schoolmen, while he stood firm as a rock against the fanaticism that sought to ally itself with the Reformation.” - Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 4, p. 152

This is an important principle. Fanaticism can sometimes disguise itself as an ally of truth. It may speak about reform, revival, health, prophecy, righteousness, or the third angel's message while introducing unsanctified ideas and methods. Therefore, God's people must know the difference between the truth itself and an unbalanced representation of the truth. The Word of God must remain our standard. “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Isaiah 8:20.

2. GIVE A DISTINCT WARNING SOUND

The church must not remain indifferent when fanaticism threatens the work of God.

“The third angel is proclaiming a most solemn message to the inhabitants of the earth; and shall God's chosen people be indifferent to it, and not unite their voice to sound this solemn warning?” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 334

There is a difference between Christian charity and cowardly silence. Love does not permit us to allow error to destroy souls.

Christ Himself warned:
“Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.” Matthew 7:15

A faithful watchman does not create unnecessary alarm, but neither does he remain silent when danger is plainly before him.

3. STAY AWAY FROM FANATICAL INFLUENCES

We must recognize that some influences are spiritually dangerous.

“If you knew just what course the servants of God ought to pursue in order to help you, you knew enough to come out yourself. God gave you your choice, to be taught, to be instructed through His servants in His own appointed way, or to go on, maintain your willful course, and fall into bewildering fanaticism.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 313

This does not mean that we should isolate ourselves from everyone who disagrees with us. Rather, it means that we must not willingly place ourselves under influences that continually produce confusion, rebellion, sensationalism, division, or contempt for God's established principles.

The Bible gives the same warning:
“Cease, my son, to hear the instruction that causeth to err from the words of knowledge.” Proverbs 19:27

4. DO NOT WAIT UNTIL FANATICISM HAS FULLY DEVELOPED

One of the most serious mistakes is to see warning signs and say, “Let us wait and see what happens.”

We have a solemn warning:
“Brother G wished to wait until the fanaticism should develop, and it went on just as Satan would have it, until it did develop with terrible results.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 313-314

The lesson is clear: Prevention is better than attempting to repair the destruction afterward. When unscriptural teachings, strange practices, sensational claims, or disorderly influences first appear, God's people should examine them carefully in the light of Scripture and sound counsel.

Paul instructed: “Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” 1 Thessalonians 5:21

5. GIVE NO PLACE TO FANATICAL INFLUENCES

Not every person who claims sincerity should automatically be given a platform or influence.

“Such are allowed to have influence, when no place should be given to them, notwithstanding their pretensions to honesty.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 326

“We cannot afford to sanction anything that would bring in confusion and weaken our zeal in regard to the great work that God has given us to do in the world to prepare for the second coming of Christ.” - Letter 338, 1908 (2SM 42)

The question therefore is not merely: “Is this person sincere?” The more important questions are:

• Does this teaching agree with Scripture?
• Does it produce Christian character?
• Does it promote unity in truth?
• Does it exalt Christ?
• Does it strengthen the third angel's message?
• Does it produce order rather than confusion?
• Does it lead souls toward obedience or toward human authority?

6. STRENGTHEN OUR POSITION BY DWELLING UPON THE WORD

This is one of the most important safeguards against fanaticism.

“We are to strengthen our position by dwelling on the Word, and by avoiding all oddities and strange exercisings that some would be very quick to catch up and practice.” - Manuscript 115, 1908 (2SM 44)

Notice the balance. The answer is not simply: “Avoid fanaticism.” It is: “Dwell on the Word.” A person who spends more time chasing sensational claims than studying Scripture is vulnerable to deception. The Bereans provide the proper example: “These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.” Acts 17:11

7. LIFT UP THE VOICE AGAINST FANATICISM

Sister White stated:
“Whenever I have been called to meet fanaticism in its varied forms, I have received clear, positive, and definite instruction to lift my voice against its influence.” - Letter 36, 1911 (2SM 28)

There are times when silence becomes complicity. If a teaching is genuinely destructive, God's servants should not be afraid to identify the danger. But this must be done in the spirit of Christ, not in anger, pride, ridicule, or personal revenge. The purpose of rebuke is restoration and protection.

“Them that sin rebuke before all, that others also may fear.” 1 Timothy 5:20

“Sister White further told of how she was called upon repeatedly to meet this fanaticism squarely and to rebuke it sternly in the name of the Lord.” - Selected Messages, book 3, p. 371

Why? Because fanaticism diverts attention from the Word of God.

“If we as a church were to give place to any form of fanaticism, the minds of unbelievers would be diverted from the living word to the doings of mortal men.” - Selected Messages, book 3, p. 371

This is particularly important in health reform. If people see Christianity as primarily a collection of dietary restrictions, strange practices, human tests, or eccentric behavior, they may never see Christ and His righteousness. Health reform must serve the Gospel-not replace it.

9. CALL ERROR BY ITS RIGHT NAME

“We have reached a time when things are to be called by their right name.” - The Southern Watchman, April 5, 1904 (2SM 26)

This requires spiritual discernment. We should not call:

• fanaticism “revival,”
• confusion “the moving of the Spirit,”
• human opinions “present truth,”
• extremism “faithfulness,”
• presumption “boldness,”
• rebellion “independence,”
• sensationalism “the Loud Cry,”
• or human standards “God's law.”

At the same time, we must not call genuine reform fanaticism merely because it challenges our preferences. The Word of God must determine the difference.

10. MEET FANATICISM DECIDEDLY

“I was instructed that fanaticism similar to that which we were called to meet after the passing of the time in 1844 would come in among us again in the closing days of the message, and that we must meet this evil just as decidedly now as we met it in our early experiences.” - RH January 28, 1909 (1SM 221)

The closer we come to the end, the more important this warning becomes. Satan has two methods: Fanaticism on one side and cold formalism on the other. One produces excitement without obedience. The other produces profession without spiritual life. The remedy is neither extreme. The remedy is living faith working by love and producing obedience to God's Word.

11. REBUKE FANATICISM FEARLESSLY

“The Lord used us as instruments to rebuke these fanatics, and to open the eyes of His faithful people to the true character of their work.” - RH November 20, 1883 (2SM 27)

Fear of criticism must never become greater than our fear of God. Yet courage must be joined with humility. We should never rebuke another merely because he does not agree with our personal preference. Our question must always be: What saith the Lord?

12. CLOSE THE DOOR BY ESTABLISHING GOSPEL ORDER

This is one of the most important principles in the entire study.

“I saw that this door at which the enemy comes in to perplex and trouble the flock can be shut. I inquired of the angel how it could be closed. He said, ‘The church must flee to God's Word and become established upon gospel order, which has been overlooked and neglected.’” - Early Writings, p. 100

Notice the connection: God's Word plus Gospel Order equals Protection against confusion.

Fanaticism thrives where there is: disorder, independent authority, rejection of accountability, disregard for church discipline, competing messages, personal revelations above Scripture, and refusal to submit to biblical order.

The apostles understood this principle. “Let all things be done decently and in order.” 1 Corinthians 14:40

Gospel order is not human domination. It is biblical organization designed to protect the church, preserve unity, and facilitate the mission.

13. CONDEMN FANATICISM, NOT PEOPLE

“We must as workers be united in frowning down and condemning anything that bears the least approach to evil, in our associations with one another.” - RH November 20, 1885 (2SM 29)

The distinction is important. We oppose error, but we seek the salvation of the person. Christ's method was: “The truth shall make you free.” John 8:32. Our purpose must therefore be redemptive rather than vindictive. We are not seeking enemies. We are seeking to rescue souls from deception.

14. FREE OURSELVES FROM FANATICISM AND COUNTERACT ITS INFLUENCE

It is easy to condemn fanaticism in others while failing to recognize it in ourselves. Ellen White rebuked those who, after being involved in fanaticism, spent their energy defending themselves instead of correcting the damage.

“Instead of working with all your energy to free yourself and counteract the influence you exerted, you came up out of all this excusing yourself and censuring those whom God sent to you.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 313

True repentance does not say: “Everyone else misunderstood me.” True repentance asks: “Lord, what have I done, and how can I make it right?”

15. CONFESS OUR FAULTS

The way out of fanaticism includes repentance.

“You must confess your faults without censuring any other one, and cease complaining that your brethren have neglected you.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 322

“Confess your faults one to another, and pray one for another, that ye may be healed.” James 5:16

Confession is not weakness. Confession is strength because it requires humility. A person who cannot admit that he has been wrong is in danger of becoming increasingly hardened in error.

16. USE BIBLICAL CHURCH DISCIPLINE WHEN NECESSARY

There are circumstances in which persistent divisiveness cannot simply be ignored. Ellen White connected Gospel order with the protection of the church:

“I saw that if God's people in Wisconsin would prosper, they must take a decided position in regard to these things, and thereby cut off the influence of those who are causing distraction and division by teaching sentiments contrary to the body. Such are wandering stars. They seem to emit a little light; they profess and carry along a little truth, and thus deceive the inexperienced. Satan endows them with his spirit, but God is not with them; His Spirit does not dwell in them.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 1, p. 327

This does not authorize arbitrary exclusion of anyone who disagrees with us. Church discipline must be biblical, fair, patient, and orderly.

Jesus gave the pattern:
“Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone...” Matthew 18:15

If the matter remains unresolved, the biblical process continues. The goal of discipline should be restoration, protection, and preservation of the unity of the church in truth.

17. TAKE THE MIDDLE PATH AND SHUN EXTREMES

This principle summarizes much of Ellen White's counsel on health reform and fanaticism:

“You need not go into the water, or into the fire, but take the middle path, avoiding all extremes.” - Letter 57, 1886 (CD 211)

The middle path does not mean compromise with sin. It means refusing to create extremes where God has not created extremes.

We must be:

• strict where God is strict,
• moderate where God permits liberty,
• silent where Scripture is silent,
• decisive where Scripture is decisive,
• patient with the weak,
• firm against deliberate rebellion,
• and always centered upon Christ.

Back to top ⇧

FANATICISM AND IGNORANCE

One of the greatest dangers is religious enthusiasm without sound knowledge.

“The experience of some had been obtained among a class of religious fanatics who had no true sense of the exalted character of the work. The religious experience of this class of professed Seventh-day Adventists was not reliable. They had not firm principles underlying all their actions. They were self-confident, and boastful. Their religion did not consist in righteous acts, true humility of soul, and sincere devotion to God, but in impulse, in noise and confusion, spiced with eccentricities and oddities. They had not felt, neither could they feel, the necessity of being clothed with Christ's righteousness. They had a righteousness of their own, which was as filthy rags, and which God can in no case accept. These persons had no love for union and harmony of action. They delighted in disorder. Confusion, distraction, and diversity of opinion were their choice. They were ungovernable, unsubdued, unregenerated, and unconsecrated, and this element of confusion suited their undisciplined minds. They were a curse to the cause of God and brought the name of Seventh-day Adventists into disrepute... The fires of the day of God will consume the stubble and chaff, and there will be nothing left of any who continue in the ungodly course which they have so long loved. This class have a disrelish for the society of those whom God is truly with.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol 2, p 553-554

Sister White described a class whose religion consisted largely of: “impulse, in noise and confusion, spiced with eccentricities and oddities.” She continued: “They had no love for union and harmony of action. They delighted in disorder.” And she concluded that such an influence became: “a curse to the cause of God and brought the name of Seventh-day Adventists into disrepute.”

This is a solemn warning. Noise is not revival. Excitement is not the Holy Spirit. Strange manifestations are not necessarily spiritual manifestations. Extreme behavior is not evidence of holiness. A multitude of quotations does not prove that an interpretation is correct. Confidence is not the same as divine authority. The true test is the Word of God and the fruit produced in the life.

THE GREATEST DANGER: KNOWING THE TRUTH BUT REFUSING TO OBEY IT

After all the warnings concerning health reform, fanaticism, false standards, false unity, and spiritual deception, we must come to the most personal question: What will we do with the light God has given us?

“It is not for lack of knowledge that God's people are now perishing. They will not be condemned because they do not know the way, the truth, and the life. The truth that has reached their understanding, the light which has shone on the soul, but which has been neglected or refused, will condemn them. Those who never had the light to reject will not be in condemnation. What more could have been done for God's vineyard than has been done? Light, precious light, shines upon God's people; but it will not save them unless they consent to be saved by it, fully live up to it, and transmit it to others in darkness. God calls upon His people to act. It is an individual work of confessing and forsaking sins and returning unto the Lord that is needed. One cannot do this work for another.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol 2, p 123

So, “It is not for lack of knowledge that God's people are now perishing.” The problem is not simply lack of information. The problem is neglected light. Therefore, the purpose of this study is not to give us more material with which to judge other people. It is to bring us to repentance.

HEALTH REFORM MUST PRODUCE HOLINESS

The ultimate objective of health reform is not merely to create people who know what foods to eat. It is to prepare a people who are capable of giving themselves fully to God.

“We want to be just right every time. We want to bring our people up to the right position on the health reform. ‘Let us,’ says the apostle, ‘cleanse ourselves from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit, perfecting holiness in the fear of God.’ We must be right in order to stand in the last days.” - Testimonies for the Church, vol. 2, p. 375

This brings the entire study back to its proper center.

Health reform is not the Saviour.

Diet is not the Saviour.

Vegetarianism is not the Saviour.

A particular number of meals is not the Saviour.

A particular health practice is not the Saviour.

Ellen White is not the Saviour.

The church is not the Saviour.

Christ alone is our Saviour.

Health reform has value because it helps us surrender the whole being to Him.

THE TRUE OBJECTIVE OF REFORM

The apostle gives us the principle:
“Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Corinthians 10:31

And again:
“I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, that ye present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable unto God, which is your reasonable service.” Romans 12:1

True health reform therefore touches the entire life: What we eat. What we drink. How we work. How we rest. How we think. How we speak. How we treat others. How we use our time. How we control appetite. How we exercise. How we respond to temptation. How we serve God. And all of this must ultimately lead us to Christ.

Back to top ⇧

CONCLUSION: LET US NOT PERISH WITH THE LIGHT

We have studied the principles of health reform. We have considered temperance, diet, appetite, cleanliness, exercise, rest, fresh air, mental health, Christian character, medical missionary work, and the relationship between health reform and the third angel's message.

We have also examined the danger of fanaticism:

• making human standards equal to God's law,
• judging others by personal convictions,
• forcing conscience,
• creating tests where God has not made tests,
• neglecting the Gospel,
• producing confusion,
• separating families,
• destroying Christian unity,
• sensationalizing the message,
• and allowing health reform to become health deform.

But now the question is no longer theoretical.

What will I do with the light God has given me?

Will I use it to condemn others?

Or will I allow it to transform me?

Will I make my personal experience the standard for everyone?

Or will I allow God's Word to be my standard?

Will I become extreme?

Or will I walk humbly with God?

Will I defend health reform while neglecting Christ?

Or will I allow health reform to lead me into deeper fellowship with Christ?

Will I become obsessed with physical preparation while neglecting spiritual preparation?

Or will I prepare both body and character for the coming of the Lord?

The purpose of reform is restoration.

The purpose of health is service.

The purpose of discipline is redemption.

The purpose of truth is sanctification.

And the purpose of every genuine reform is to bring us closer to Jesus Christ.

“Sanctify them through thy truth: thy word is truth.” John 17:17

Therefore: Let us reform without becoming fanatical. Let us be temperate without becoming judgmental. Let us uphold God's standard without creating human standards. Let us teach health reform without making it the Gospel. Let us defend the commandments without neglecting the testimony of Jesus. Let us maintain Gospel order without becoming authoritarian. Let us expose error without losing Christian charity. Let us reject fanaticism without becoming indifferent to truth. And above everything else: LET US BEHOLD CHRIST.

For Jesus Christ is our only safety. If our eyes remain fixed upon Him, our health reform will have the right spirit, our reforms will have the right purpose, our preaching will have the right emphasis, and our lives will become a living testimony to the transforming power of the Gospel.

“Looking unto Jesus the author and finisher of our faith...” Hebrews 12:2

The goal is not merely to become healthier people.

The goal is to become holy people.

The goal is not merely to reform the appetite.

The goal is to surrender the appetite to Christ.

The goal is not merely to preserve the body.

The goal is to consecrate the body to God.

And when health reform is placed in its proper position-under Christ, under Scripture, and in harmony with the complete Gospel-it ceases to be a platform for controversy and becomes what God intended it to be: an instrument of preparation for Christian service and for the final proclamation of the everlasting Gospel.

“Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.” Revelation 14:12

May God preserve His people from both extremes-fanaticism and indifference-and lead us into that balanced, sanctified, obedient experience in which the body, mind, and spirit are wholly surrendered to Him.

“Even so, come, Lord Jesus.” Revelation 22:20

Back to top ⇧

KEY BIBLICAL THEMES

• 1 Corinthians 6:19-20 - The body is the temple of the Holy Ghost
• 1 Corinthians 9:25-27 - Temperance and self-control
• 3 John 2 - Prosperity and health
• Romans 12:1-2 - Presenting the body as a living sacrifice
• Daniel 1:8-20 - Temperance and faithfulness
• Genesis 1:29 - God’s original provision of food
• Genesis 3:6 - The fall connected with appetite
• Proverbs 20:1 - Warning concerning intoxicating drink
• Proverbs 23:20-21 - Gluttony and excess
• Proverbs 25:16, 27 - Moderation
• Philippians 4:5 - Christian moderation
• Galatians 5:22-23 - Temperance as a fruit of the Spirit
• 1 Corinthians 10:31 - Eating and drinking to God’s glory
• Isaiah 7:15 - Choosing good and refusing evil
• Daniel 1:8 - Purpose of heart
• Matthew 4:4 - Man’s dependence upon God’s Word
• 2 Corinthians 7:1 - Cleansing ourselves from1defilement
• Romans 14:17 - The kingdom of God is not centered in meat and drink
• Colossians 2:16 - Avoiding judgment concerning matters God has not made a test of fellowship

Back to top ⇧